Reply to Extracurriculars

Forum Index » College and University Discussion

Reply to "Extracurriculars"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]It really depends on the college. Some like the dedication shown by kids who only do a few things but have done them for long periods. I highly recommend your daughter do an interview when she applies, it will really help back up her passions. [/quote]

Spoken like a true novice to the college admissions process.  Most colleges don't do or even consider interviews, and the ones that do typically only assign it minimal weight.  I wouldn't count on turning a decision around on the basis of an interview.

The bottom line is that extracurriculars play a distant third in the process at best, behind grades, test scores and probably URM status.  In some schools they don't matter at all, and in every school where they do matter, a couple of extracurriculars seen all the way through school will trump the "serial joiner" every time.

Based on your decription of what your DD is up to, I'd say she's fine on the extracurricular front for many, many good colleges.  Maybe not Harvard, but she won't get in there with a B average anyway.

I'd stop worrying so much about extras and encourage her to pull her grades up the best she can, without stressing her out.  Beyond that, I'd leave her alone.     [/quote]

Your post just proves that ignorance and arrogance is an unbeatable combination!

OP, do not listen to this ignorant poster. We went through the college admissions process last year. [b]Many colleges do encourage and some require admissions interviews. We discovered that interviews are helpful to admissions counselors in deciding how interested your child is in their school.[/b] The only colleges DC didn't get into (or was waitlisted) were colleges that DC didn't visit or interview at, including some of her safety schools. If you can visit the college, definitely schedule an interview!

[/quote]

The above information is not correct. First, it is not clear which interview the poster is referring to but the "interview" related to the college admission process is not scheduled by the applicant. The interview is set up by the alumni interviewer and the specific date/time is agreed to by both sides. Visits to colleges have no influence on the admission decisions and "interviews" with "school alumni" have virtually non to zero impact on the admission decision as well.

Indicating that the applicant is "full-Pay" will impact the admission decision.[/quote]

I agree that full pay is useful. Not applying for FA can help your child as long as you are applying to a college that does not meet 100% of financial need. In that case, FA status makes no difference.

Also, this poster has no idea what s/he is talking about. Are you a high school troll? Get back to class!

Interviews are scheduled by the applicant. My DD applied to several selective SLACS, and she scheduled interviews at all of them. Our high school invited admissions officers from a bunch of selective colleges to visit, and many of those admissions officers told us parents that interviews, while not always necessary, can influence admissions decisions. They help the admissions officer decide whether the kid is really interested in the college, or just phoning it in. They will not make or break an application, but in this competitive environment, anything that gives a kid a slight advantage is worth pursuing.

[/quote]

OP here.  We have been told by every school we have visited that has an option to interview that it is useful.  It certainly doesn't hurt.

As things are shaping up, my DD, of course, is interested in both UVA and WM.  As of this writing, these are both reach schools. Maybe schools she is looking at include Southern Methodist University (SMU).  Not sure next where things fall next down the list.   There are several schools I've asked her to look at because they offer scholarships specific to her program of study and/or our national/ethnic/religious heritage.  I think her list will be a combination of state, private schools with student bodies in the 5 - 12K range.  She seems most comfortable with that student body size.

I don't get caught up in the HYP hype.  I know my DD is not headed there.  We are looking for a good school that where she is a good "fit" and where she will get an education that will help her to expand her worldview and help her to spread her wings.  Less than 1 percent of US undergraduates attend an Ivy League school, yet the other 99 percent (myself included) still seem to find a path to success.  [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics