Reply to Conflict around family size

Forum Index » Relationship Discussion (non-explicit)

Reply to "Conflict around family size"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]I think the people that are posting that he is too old are disregarding the fact that he was 46 or 47 when DC1 was born.  He clearly doesn't have a problem being an older dad, so it seems like he should have other reasons for not wanting to consider it.  I would understand not wanting to start down the road in your late 40s, but once you're gone, age wouldn't stop you from considering one more if you're able.  The DH may have 50 other reasons, but[b] I don't think age is very valid in this case[/b].[/quote]

Who are you to judge whether his reason is "valid?" He doesn't want another child. This is about bringing another human being into the world and is one of those situations where a "no" trumps. There is no compromise and there is no dismissing or judging someone for their reasons for not wanting one. He doesn't need to provide a whole host of reasons. [/quote]
She is his wife, and his decision to have or not to have another child is a major factor in shaping the rest of their life. Of course she has every right to judge him, and ask for every single reason he has about it.[b]  It's not right to make a decision that affects both people unilaterally, impose it on another person, and then be a dick about it.  [/b]I mean, people do it every day, but let's not pretend it is without consequences to the relationship.[/quote]

Actually in the case where it's about whether or not to have another child, this is the one time that a no-vote trumps. There really aren't any other decisions in a family where this is the case. But with having another child, if one person doesn't want one, then it doesn't happen. I'm not saying it's easy or that the spouse who does want a child is obligated to stay or that there won't be any consequences. It's just not the same as a decision such as where to live or whether one parent will stay home or work outside the home. [/quote]

Original PP here.  His no vote may well end up trumping, but wouldn't he make it easier on his wife to at least tell her why in a rational way?  It sounds like it isn't just about the fact that he is saying no but how he is saying no.  If it isn't age, give the real reasons.  If it is the age, cop to the fact that you found DC1 too tiring and can't do it again.  [b]Shutting down gives OP the pain of both not having a chance at the family she wants and feeling like she isn't even afforded the respect of an explanation - a bad double whammy, one that definitely could end the marriage[/b].[/quote]
Yes. I'm going through this right now.  DH and I always, always planned more than one, and then he abruptly turned around by saying "it's too much responsibility."  I am in so much pain.  He dismisses all attempts I make to discuss this rationally.  We have a 4-year old and it absolutely kills me that he may be an only child.  And the sadder thing yet is that I can see growing to hate DH over this, in a lasting way.  I can't look at him. I feel no love for him whatsoever. He isn't even acknowledging that his turnaround is bringing me this excruciating pain. I don't know if this will end the marriage.  I do know that right now, I do not feel the same commitment or loyalty to him any more. He betrayed me.[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics