Reply to Couldn't you just build a strong proximity preference to get the advantages of choice sets?

Forum Index » DC Public and Public Charter Schools

Reply to "Couldn't you just build a strong proximity preference to get the advantages of choice sets?"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]Let's not forget there is a rezoning going on as well. In the popular school neighborhood of Murch and Janney the school zone borders will change. This concerns a significant group of parents / families. These people are the among the closest to Murch or Janney respectively, like literally 2- 3 blocks away. Their newly assigned school would be Hearst, which is one mile away. Say goodbye to walkability

In the choice set their schools would be: Hearst (at 1 mile), Eaton (at 1.4 miles) and Oyster (at 2.7 miles)!!!! what on earth can this mean in terms of proximity, walkability, neighborhood preference??

Furthermore, these families are a stone's throw away from Deal as middle school. Because of the rezoning to Hearst at one block away, their middle school would be Hardy at 2.7 miles!!

What kind of urban planning disaster is this?[/quote]

Also, I agree this is very upsetting for these families (and the schools whom these families are a part of) and, at least at Janney, the school is not currently overcrowded with the renovation that is happening and the DME paperwork acknowledged that.  That said, there are many, many houses within the Hearst boundary that are very close to Janney, walkable to Janney and much farther away to Hearst.  That is the nature of how the schools were placed.  They are in a cluster with houses moving outward from them.  The families in the middle are closer to all three than the families on the outer edges of the boundaries.  There is, however, no way to move the schools or assign the families farther away to Hearst without having those families pass Janney on their way to Hearst, which is even more ridiculous.  And those families moved to Hearst are no farther than many families within the boundaries.  Given that the DME states in its paperwork that it is trying to further walkability with the changes it needs to acknowledge that it is actually taking walkable homes within boundaries and making them unwalkable.

[/quote]

I agree that change and potential change is upsetting.  and agree with your comment that because all 3 of hearst, janney and murch are actually quite close together the blocks around where the 3 boundaries meet are in a tricky spot.  However the comment about ALL potential janney homes who could be rezoned to hearst would have to pass janney, i think it overstates -

the small group of houses between nebraska on the west and wisconsin on the east from Yuma to van ness are already south of janney, they would just keep going south to van ness and then head a couple blocks east - would not pass Janney

the blocks west of wisconsin avenue to 38th street between yuma and chesapeake could walk south on 38th until Upton and then head 1 block west to 37th.  so sure on south/north axis they go further south than Janney is located but they would not actually pass janney on their walk

So, yes for the 'furthest' murch houses it is a potential 12 block max walk vs what is currently 4 or 5 , yes it is further but still walkable or bikeable.  and if grandfathering is set up for all existing [b]families - or geez - even all existing homeowners - why not make the change to end up with another strong neighborhood school in the N Cleveland Park/Tenley/AU area?   our neighborhood has plenty of kids to fill 3 great elementary schools and if we can agree to this in exchange for tossing out the choice set concept or the crazy lottery ideas for MS and HS well that's a bargain I'd be willing to agree too. [/b]

[/quote]

PP here. Yes, I can live with that. If the choice set in the neighborhood described above would be Murch, Janney or Hearst; that would be acceptable. However, one proposal creates a lottery between Hearst, Oyster or Eaton! The latter two are surely not walkable anymore from that Janney / Murch axis described above. Oyster is in a different neighborhood altogether.[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics