Reply to can someone explain biobanding like I am a third grader?

Forum Index » Soccer

Reply to "can someone explain biobanding like I am a third grader?"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]Club thinks player will get bigger when they hit puberty. Currently they're a decent player and have the potential to be much more after puberty. So you play this kid against younger players until they hit puberty. At that time they go back to playing against players their age.

Unfortunately many clubs play ringers down against younger teams for wins. Which defeats the purpose of biobanding.

Its the difference between short term and long term thinking.[/quote]

i've seen teams play a clearly not undersized older kid down in their games mid-season. surely this isn't what biobanding is intended to be? totally get kids who are small at beginning of season playing down who grow during season. don't get large kids just playing down just to win. seems a bit like cheating and how does this help the kid who isn't small, playing with and against younger competition.[/quote]

Any time my kid has played against bigger players, I see it as great practice for my kid to rely on technique and to play under pressure. I think those parents and players who make a fuss about bio banded players care way too much about winning which is all you need to know about the level of player they have. Pretend concern for the biobanded kid is just pretext.

[/quote]

Bioband player steals a top team spot from a younger player who loses the opportunity to grow. [/quote]

Oh please, a younger player thinking something was stolen from them is not going to go very far. Drop to rec.[/quote]

Why does the Bioband player have to steal a younger player's spot? Instead of forcing the younger player to drop to rec, why not have the bioband player try to play in his own age group? Just don't be a cheater. The shame will stay with you.[/quote]

Why don’t you just raise a player in an environment with less whining and blaming?  Drop them to rec if that’s where they will thrive. But MLSNext is not where they belong if you care this much about biobanded players.

You’re assuming my player is biobanded because I’m defending biobanded players. He’s not but him and teammates don’t care about who is biobanded or not because they’re confident about their skills. At MLSNext, you’re already playing teams that skew more like SYC in size, a biobanded player makes zero difference in the competition. I bet you’re also complaining that SYC players and similar teams should play their oversized players up.

Raise a player that has a tougher mentality. No one wants a whiner on their team. [/quote]

Hope there are 3 biobanding players in your team and take 3 spots playing full time soon.
[/quote]

Spoken like a parent who has to worry about something like that happening to their player. Use it as a lesson for your player to work harder and ignore your whining. [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics