Reply to Math track at TJ and college admissions

Forum Index » Advanced Academic Programs (AAP)

Reply to "Math track at TJ and college admissions"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]What matters is that your child took hard classes that were available at their school, that is going to be different based on the school and the school district. FCPS is unusual in that it allows kids to start HS math in 7th grade, now testing 6th grade. Most places in the country see Algebra 1 in 8th grade as the accelerated track, very few places in the US allow for a regular pathway to Algebra 1 in 7th grade. Colleges are developing and posting baseline standards to take into consideration the norm across the country. The norm across the country is to complete Calculus as a senior, BC being the most rigorous Calc class. As much as people on this board and in this area complain about the schools, kids at FCPS have access to many more classes and programs then their counterparts across the country. Colleges know that and are taking that into consideration when reviewing an applicant from TJ or McLean or Langley or South Lakes or Lewis. They know what is on offer and it is above the baseline that exists for most schools in the country.

[b]That said, at schools where there are other options, like pretty much every HS in FCPS, a strong math student is expected to have taken Calc BC but the strongest math students, the ones who took Algebra before 8th grade, are expected to have multi-variate and linear algebra when applying to top STEM programs because they are available at the school. [/b]

A student applying to a top school who is interested in the humanities is likely fine with Calc AB and or AP Stats. A student who took Algebra 1 in 7th grade and is interested in the humanities should have both, they don't need multi-variate calculus because they are not interested in engineering or other STEM programs. They need more APs in English, Social Studies, History and the other humanities.

All of the kids applying to top schools need AP History, English, Social Studies, and Science classes on top of the math classes. A STEM kid doesn't need every AP History/English/Social Studies class but they do need at least one in each category and then AP Science and Math classes across the board.[/quote]

There’s not a lot of evidence for it. Multivariable and Linear Algebra at TJ and other magnet schools are high school elective classes, won’t even get the same credit as community college courses.

Students that take Multivariable and linear algebra usually have higher GPA, work harder, have better extracurriculars, which make them stronger applicants. It’s not the light version of these classes that get them in.

There are numerous posts every year of students with 15+ AP and DE classes shut out of top 20. If these classes were that important they get in, but that’s not happening.[/quote]

They are also competing against students with similar profiles for a small number of spots at any given college. The pool of applicants looks reasonably similar, including taking multi-variate calculus and linear algebra, either at their school or a community college or at a college in the area. There are kids who don't have those classes that are accepted but they are most likely coming from an area with fewer options for kids and they are not expected to have those classes.

Some of those kids applying for Engineering programs, which are even smaller in number and more competitive, won't be accepted at the school while a kid applying for a humanities program at the same selective school will be accepted with Calc BC.

[b]I have yet to see any data that shows that a kid taking Calc BC is more likely to be accepted into the engineering program at MIT then the kid from the same school with multi-variate calculus.[/b]

More importantly, kids strong in math who like math should be taking the higher level classes because it challenges and stretches them and not just to get into MIT or Cal Tech. DS is taking geometry in 8th grade because he is strong in math and enjoys it. I expect that he will take more advanced math classes because he loves math. He might not get into MIT but he will go to a strong college because he will have good grades and will have taken many challenging classes in HS. It would be great if he attends MIT but it is a long shot, even if he has A's in all of his classes and takes a full load of APs/IBs/DE. It comes down to a small number of spots and a lot of people wanting those spots.[/quote]

That’s not the point being made.

The clam is that Multivariable and other DE courses alone don’t significantly improve the admissions prospects at top colleges. The supporting evidence is what colleges themselves say on their webpages.[/quote]

What they say on their webpage doesn’t matter.  You are being compared to the other applicants.  [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics