Reply to Eureka math. Is it the right way to learn math?

Forum Index » Elementary School-Aged Kids

Reply to "Eureka math. Is it the right way to learn math? "

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]Our school switched from Eureka to Bridges in 2nd grade. Eureka sucked for K and 1- it had some really specific concepts and vocabulary that were hard for me to understand as an adult who has taken math through college and grad school. Maybe I had bad math professors or maybe it’s Eureka-specific jargon? I was deep into the curriculum since much of K was virtual and I was ready to set Eureka on fire by March. I may be misremembering, but in 1st grade it was lots of place value nonsense and my DD did not have sufficient grasp of math basics to tackle that by Eureka’s methods I know Eureka does a lot of non-grade level challenge stuff but it felt like every 5th problem was out of left field.

Some of the Eureka approaches are basically the same as Bridges but Bridges is less painful from a parent perspective and my DD “gets” math better now. The story problems are still rambling and stupid and I hate the multiple ways they have to “show your work”, but my DD has become way better at math.

+1 to the PP who said to learn the Eureka vocabulary. If I’d had a translator from day 1 I probably would have learned a lot alongside my DD![/quote]

Can you explain the difficulty in more detail? Place value isn't nonsense; it's the core of how numbers work.

It's OK to not understand everything. Math spirals and repeats a lot every year to build foundations. If every problem in the book were easy for everyone, then everyone would be learning less than they could!

Especially in K-2, where unfortunately everyone is taking the same material, even though in 10 years you'll have some kids in Multivariablre Calculus and some kids in Algebra 1.[/quote]

My kids went through Eureka in elementary, and now are in very advanced math programs in secondary school. They both felt that Eureka was very helpful, and I can see myself that they understood numbers in a way that I didn't at their age. One of the best things about Eureka for me was that I finally "got" math once I went through the lessons with them. Now I myself feel more confident in the subject![/quote]

Completely agree. My kids find Eureka slow and boring, but like a PP said, it seems like there's a lot of repetition to build foundations. I was a kid that breezed through elementary and advanced middle school math, but then hit a wall with advanced high school math. I could memorize easily, but didn't have a good foundation understand math when it got too difficult. I think there are always some kids that naturally "get" math and don't need explicit instruction (like phonics instruction for reading), but others that could do better in advanced math with more explicit foundational knowledge. Not sure if Eureka is the best way to teach that, and definitely has significant weaknesses for the significant number of kids that struggle with the Eureka methods, but it's definitely better than how we were taught in the 80-90s.

And I don't think Eureka methods are completely novel. I remember my mother trying to teach me little math tricks as a kid, and being surprised I wasn't learning them in school like she did in the 60s. Looking at what my elementary kids are doing now, I see the similarities between what my mom called her tricks and the Eureka methods. I think I would have been a better math student if I had gone through Eureka, but maybe that's just wishful thinking. But because there are so many kids that struggle with it and so many others that find it slow and repetitive, I wouldn't be at all surprised if it falls out of favor in the future, but I hope it's replaced with a better system for teaching the foundations and conceptual understanding, and not just a return to memorization.[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics