Reply to Stopped IF…losing weight?

Forum Index » Diet, Nutrition & Weight Loss

Reply to "Stopped IF…losing weight?"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote]But there are benefits of fasting, even if 15/16 hours. Eating 9-6 is still plenty of time to eat.

Not saying there aren't benefits, but if you lose weight by "fasting"/skipping a meal then it is all due to reduction in calories not because you didn't eat for 16 hrs. If you you needs 2000 cal to maintain it's current weight then you could eat your those calories in 2 hrs, 8 hr, or 24 hours and guess what you will stay the same weight.[/quote]

well, yes and no. [b]Its also like saying calories are calories and it doesn'tmatter what you eat. [/b]We know now that's not true and different foods have different effects. Longer periods without food generally correlates to better insulin sensitivity which correlates to less fat storage.  it can also help with hunger itself---once you get used to it, you realize that snacking all the time isnot necessary, maybe even adding to your hunger so if overeating is a problem then IF can be good.

many other health benefits accrue from reducing the number of times you eat a day, including/esp autophagy. I think a reasonable approach is that of Dr. Valter Longo, who encourages a 14 hour period (overnight really); a mediterranean diet, and occasional short fasts for autophagy purposes. Fasting essentially halts the production of IFG1, which is a growth signalling hormone--and that causes everything to grow, including tumors. This is why fasting is being studied in cancer patients.  That being said, for most people most of the time there's not a huge benefit to fasting 18 hours versus 14. I do IF mainly because I have a low caloric need daily and prefer to get most of my calories in two meals rather than 3 plus a snack, which would limit me to 400 calorie meals.

[/quote]

Totally different point. Sure some calories have more nutritional benefits and will keep you full longer/make you feel better but at the end of the day a calorie is nothing more than a unit used to measure how much energy food give you. An apple can give you 100 cal of energy just like a piece of chocolate any energy not used from this food will be stored at fat.

[b]Again not arguing that there can be health benefits to fasting but at the end of the day your body needs X calories to survive. If you eat that many you stay the same weight. if you eat too many you store that energy for later in the form of fat. If you eat too few calories you burn your energy stores[/b]. 
[/quote]

Disagree with this.  Go on a low carb diet.  Eat more calories by eating mostly bacon, eggs and steak.  You’ll lose weight rapidly and lose more and more.  That diet alone proves that it’s not just calories in / calories out.  [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics