Reply to Spanish in elementary schools

Forum Index » DC Public and Public Charter Schools

Reply to "Spanish in elementary schools"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]Since DCPS no longer requires world languages at schools, many schools have cut their language teachers or repurposed the money for other uses.  And it will get worse next year since quite a few schools (at least in Upper NW, but I am sure in other places too) received a large chunk of their budgets in "one time" funds that will go away.  So more cuts are coming...[/quote]

That’s a shame.  Kids may not be fluent but exposure to another language, culture, customs is something worthwhile especially for kids who don’t have the luxury of travel.

The NW kids will be fine.  They will be traveling internationally and get the exposure.  It’s the kids who don’t have that luxury and being exposed to something outside their world that will miss out more.[/quote]

I agree with the first line in this post.  Language classes should be judged not just on whether the students become fluent (they are not going to in a once or even twice a week class), but exposure is helpful to learning.  You learn an ear for the language, and keep the part of your brain that learns language growing.  I took spanish lessons in school (2x/week) through elementary school and my accent sounds almost native, and it was easy to pick up the language in high school.  And I learned about Spanish-speaking cultures.  Sadly, I do not think the DCPS curriculum was great.  At least at our school, following DCPS curriculum, it was mostly worksheets and videos, before they dropped it.

However, I wouldn't assume that NW kids are unharmed by dropping language instructions.  Sure, they will travel, but there is a difference between going to a foreign country where everyone at your resort speaks English, and learning how to strike off on your own.  And kids don't get to do much striking off on their own.  And kids from wealthier families don't get any baked in second language acquisition like they do with English, unless they are a bilingual family.  I should be figuring out ways to get more language instruction for my kids, but I haven't figured out the best avenue for a kid in an otherwise great DCPS.[/quote]

Is there a way for you to teach people confidence?  I admire your confidence in your ability to speak Spanish.

I really really doubt your accent sounds “near native”, but I’m glad you feel so proud of it![/quote]

lol I wish.  My point was that my accent is better than my fluency.  After studying in school i moved abroad, which obviously helped with picking up the language, but if you don't learn from a young age, I think it's harder for people to pick up the sound of a language.  I worked with people who spoke better spanish than me, but they never really picked up the accent as well.  Having not used my spanish as much now that I'm old and boring, my accent is still good, but I've lost a lot of my vocabulary from disuse.  So when i start speaking it, people start the conversation thinking I'm fluent and are very quickly disabused of that notion.[/quote]

This is an interesting point. How much language class until that accent is picked up? You may just have a knack for the accent. My kids in immersion have great accents. I grew up with a little French in an after school club and high school French and have zero accent. Once a week from PK age might do it but I’m not sure. [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics