Reply to MCPS and Starr will probably need to change boundaries

Forum Index » Montgomery County Public Schools (MCPS)

Reply to "MCPS and Starr will probably need to change boundaries"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]

"Redistributing kids" won't solve the problem.  Kids self-segregate - even in some very diverse schools.  In the "W schools," they'll self-segregate by money.  Do you honestly think some kid living in low-income housing will be welcomed by the kid in the mansion?  doubtful

And sprinkling in a few kids coming from disadvantaged homes will make them stand out, as most will be black and Hispanic.  Is that fair?

If I had the answer, I'd be a millionaire. But I know that this solution will not work either.  [/quote]

This solution actually does work.

I don't know if a kid in a mansion will welcome a kid living in low-income housing, and I don't know if it's fair to make disadvantaged kids to stand out.

What I do know is that the educational outcomes for poor kids are a lot better in low-poverty schools than in high-poverty schools.[/quote]

which fails to take into account grade inflation - as the pressure is on to pass minority students

Talk to any of the Hispanic and black males who come out of a W school and enter alternative settings.  Ask them how comfortable they felt in a W school.  It's not just about grades, which mean nothing in this day and age.  It's about well-being.

Finally, [b]let's see how accepting the neighborhoods in Bethesda, Chevy Chase and Potomac will be if the county decides to change boundaries.  You will have a fight on your hands as property values immediately plummet - especially if low-incoming housing is thrown into the mix[/b].

So even IF the kids are welcoming, their parents won't be.[/quote]

So what?  We all bought houses in MoCo, districted to MCPS.  No one is entitled to a specific school with specific demographics, no matter how much they paid for their house.  No one.[/quote]

Are you for real?  Do you genuinely not understand that people pay more for houses in certain school districts?  It's not about entitlement, it's about getting what you pay (and scrimp and save and sacrifice other things) for.  [/quote]

That is not how it works.  People can pay whatever they want for whatever quality they perceive, but that payment does not create a contract with the county (or anyone else).  [b]We all pay the same taxes to the same county for the same school district, MCPS.[/b]  We are all entitled to have our children educated by MCPS.  MCPS can organize schools however it sees fit, to deliver that education.

If you want the guarantee of kids from five miles away not sitting next to your kid in her classroom, then buy a house in a town-based system.  MCPS is a large school district, and we are ALL entitled to the SAME education by virtue of living here.[/quote]
If you pay a $200-$400K premium to buy a house in a v. good school district, you will pay more in property taxes .[/quote]

[b]You pay the same rate.  The exact same rate.
[/b]
Which is the point of a county-based (versus a town-based) school system.[/quote]

I know I pay the same rate but I pay more in taxes because my house has a higher market value so as far as I can tell, I contribute more to school funding than I did when I lived in my DCC house.  I am aware that these funds are pooled which is fine with me BUT I did want to make the point that I do contribute more in tax funding of the school system now than I did when I lived in the DCC.     [/quote]

Actually, what you said was that you pay more in taxes to buy a house in a "v. good school district."  This is not accurate.  You pay the same tax rate to live in the same school district that you were living in previously, in your DCC house.  You are not entitled to better schools as a result of your choice to pay more for your house.  You may be getting better schools (or perceive that you are), but you are not entitled to better schools.

If that wasn't the point of you saying that you pay more taxes, then what was your point?[/quote]

Are you the same poster that was arguing non-sensically earlier?
[b]WE GET THAT MCPS IS ONE DISTRICT.[/b]
You MUST be being purposefully obtuse at this point.  [/quote]

Actually, there are many posters on this thread who do not seem to grasp that concept.  Who keep referring to where they live as a "v. good school district" and the like - as if it were an entity unto itself.  Who are insistent that their choice to "sacrifice" to pay a high mortgage means they get a different school district than those in eastern MoCo.

Read through the thread and you will see many examples of people who do not get it.
[/quote]

Literally, of course. Please don't be so dense. It's painful.[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics