Reply to Stanford admissions success stories

Forum Index » College and University Discussion

Reply to "Stanford admissions success stories "

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]My son got in spring 2023.  He had 4.0 unweighted, 1580 SAT, all 5s on APs, good ECs, but not anything award winning.  He plans to major in Political Science or History so not anything STEM.  I have no idea what got him in, but he did get a note from the woman who read his application about his essays, so maybe that was it.

He ended up choosing not to go.  Too far and too expensive.  He's at UVA and is very happy.  [/quote]

It's a shame that people apply to schools they have no intention on attending....

Honestly, what about far and too expensive did you not know in advance?[/quote]

Seriously. People like this are taking away opportunities from their peers at their high school. Absolutely awful behavior by this family. If you don't want to go to Stanford or other highly selective schools, don't apply. Just go to UVA. Why take these possibilities away from other students at your high school? Nothing about Stanford's location or cost is mysterious. But highly selective universities will only take x amount of students from a particular high school, and this one took one away from someone that probably really wanted to attend. For no reason at all except the bragging rights. Pathetic.     [/quote]

This is a joke, right?  I never said anything about Stanford being a mystery.  Obviously we know where it is and how much it costs.  Could we have paid full tuition?  Yes.  But it would have made us make significant changes in our lifestyle.  After he got in to both UVA and Stanford and some other schools, we talked about it and decided it wasn't worth it.  And he didn't take away a spot from anyone at his school - he wasn't at a private or one of the public schools where everyone applies to Ivies - he was the only one in his class who applied to Stanford and one of the few who applied to Ivies.  Ugh, I don't even know why I am engaging you, but it pisses me off that you're assuming devious intent by my then 17 year old son.  [/quote]

Trophy hunting is a real thing at a lot of schools that do have a lot of applicants to Stanford and the like. So it gets people really riled up to see someone turn down such a hard acceptance for the reasons stated - location and cost. Which, duh. All well known. So the assumption is trophy hunting. You are very blessed to live in an area where you are the only applicant to selective schools and can make such choices without impacts to others.  [/quote]

It is not trophy hunting. I am a DP and we seriously considered UPenn vs. UVA when the cost of attendance was $70k v. $32K. But when UVA offered full tuition scholarship and comparison became $70k. v. $10k per year, UVA won. [/quote]

You are in a different scenario than what people are talking about here.[/quote]

Exactly. And that was unclear from the original post. [b]It's a totally different scenario at a high school with a lot of kids applying to selective colleges.[/b] It did read like someone racking up acceptances with no intention of going. I mean people know where Stanford is. And how much it is going to cost them if they are not eligible for aid. So why apply if it's too far and you don't want to pay for it? But if it's someone applying from a small town with few applicants to such schools and they're just exploring possibilities, good for them. At a place like Sidwell or TJ, where there are a lot of kids applying to Stanford and the like, it's going to bring out some eye rolls. Trophy hunters - racking up acceptances with no intention of going - really do affect their peer students. [/quote]
Well, not always. Take some “lesser” Virginia public that Stanford has not accepted anyone to in the last 10 years. Say there were 12 or so applications (doesn’t matter; could be 8). Then the high school gets an admit — after all, it was their due. And that admit does not yield. Enough said…[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics