Reply to Discussion over whether to expand Tyler dual-lang program turns to gentrification debate

Forum Index » DC Public and Public Charter Schools

Reply to "Discussion over whether to expand Tyler dual-lang program turns to gentrification debate"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]One challenge with immersion is that it's hard for kids to join in when they move in later grades, and poorer kids in DC tend to move more. What do you do when a 4th grader moves IB for a dual-language school or when the charter they've been in counsels them out mid-year?

I think Tyler should go dual-language and Brent should be monolingual (or vice versa), and students in both boundaries should be able to rank their preferences for each. You'd be guaranteed a seat in one of them and there'd be sibling preference to keep families together. Then there would be lots more dual language slots and everyone would still have a monolingual alternative if they wanted it, and both schools would have more racial and economic diversity.[/quote]

Hate this idea.  YOu don't seem to know that Brent is bursting at the seams.  Seen the new trailers on the small playground?

No room at Brent for most IB parent who want PreS3 and PreK4 let alone IB Tyler families who'd reject Spanish![/quote]

Then make Brent dual language and Tyler monolingual. It's the same number of IB kids in the combined boundary either way. [/quote]

And where will you put the OOB Spanish-dominant students? that would have to go at Brent? The Brent families would all have to have IB rights to their neighborhood school. That's why these programs all begin in under=enrolled buildings. [/quote]

The Tyler and Brent boundaries would have two IB schools: Brent and Tyler. You'd have a right to attend one of those schools, and a right to express a preference as to which one you got, but you could get either of them. If the combined boundary for the two schools can't handle the number of kids then it's time to shift the boundary, sending more kids to the Cluster or Payne.[/quote]

I don't think DCPS is going to implement a choice-set in just two elementary schools. Try again. [/quote]

I agree. Each dual-language DCPS that doesn't have a monolingual track should have a choice-set, ideally with a desirable monolingual school. If Tyler goes 100% dual-language, Brent should be Tyler's.[/quote]

Dual language schools don't make sense as neighborhood schools unless the neighborhood has many native speakers in the second language. It would make more sense to make Tyler dual language city-wide and absorb the Tyler boundaries into the surrounding schools as space permits.[/quote]

So by this logic, Oyster, Tyler, Houston should not have dual language programs, or should be city-wide. [/quote]

Oyster’s Spanish-dominant lottery is a de facto citywide lottery.  Children from Spanish speaking homes come from all over DC, and they are admitted via that lottery—that’s why Oyster is 56% OOB. The English-dominant side is pretty much all IB, and this set-up works very well for Oyster.  We don’t need anyone to fix a school that isn’t broken.[/quote]

It is NOT a city-wide lottery, because the only English-dominant students who can get in must live IB, in one of the most expensive parts of town. This puts a very coveted resource in the hands of white affluent, and Latino students and tends to shut out many (not all) African Americans.

This is exactly what some of the AA families are Tyler don't want to happen to their school.

[/quote]

Reading (comprehension) is fundamental.  I said that “Oyster’s SPANISH-dominant lottery is a de facto citywide lottery.”  The English-dominant side is really IB only.  If your family speaks English, and you can’t afford to live within Oyster’s boundary, you’re basically SOL.  You may not like that fact, but where’s your argument with my statement?  [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics