Reply to Bethesda coaching slate for 21-22 year

Forum Index » Soccer

Reply to "Bethesda coaching slate for 21-22 year"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]

"Parent of a kid on the team. For the record, a defender was promoted at U11 and starts. Another defender was promoted at U12 and starts. A midfielder was promoted at U13 and starts. A forward/midfielder was promoted midyear and now starts on the U14 team. I am not sure what your point is. Can’t be that BSC fails to promote. Maybe you’re saying no or few promotions at or after U14, but that’s true at all ECNL clubs. [/quote]"

My point is [b]you are not a 'Parent of a kid on the team."[/b]  You are a parent of a kid on the ECNL 1 team.

Stop the party line BSC crap; Also you came over when they went 11 v 11 from Rush. It is very obvious as to who you are despite how you think you are all stealth.

The original issue I had was not how much time is devoted to the team. That is not a huge difference. It is that whomever from BSC was writing is lying when they say promotion happens from within. It does not. Call me mad, angry, drunk, what you will. Yes I am mad. It is infuriating to see that line over and over.

Ok big guy (and I am sure you are the big guy from team 1) how many times has your team practiced with ours? (2 scrimmages one of which Kevin didnt watch is the answer) How many kids have come up in the free flowing way that email from Kevin/BSC stated? 0. Your stats. 1 came up at u 13. Right before 11 v 11. Totally agree and I cited it. U12 defender was playing most of the time with top team. Athletic but raw and came from OUTSIDE club and was up within a year. Your U14 was promoted 1. when a couple kids quit and 2. she was on the 2nd team 1 month. Came from outside.  THERE IS NO PROMOTION FROM WITHIN WHICH WAS MY POINT. and a response to a crappy BSC propaganda email.

It is worse the year up. I dont have visibility into other years like I am sure you do big guy.  My statements were 100% accurate. You are on the first team telling me how it is on our team. Sort of mansplaning  down. [/quote]

I’m the person who wrote the first post above about the 4 girls promoted to the 07 team over the last 4 years. I’m not the “big guy” fwiw.

My post was simply a response to the post on Sunday night at 9:18 pm from you or someone else claiming that not 1 single girl had been promoted from the second team. I gave you several examples from the 07 team that disproved your point, and I am glad you later acknowledged that at least 1 girl was promoted from the second team to the first team. The girl promoted for the U13 season - and who now starts as a midfielder - played for several years on the second team before being promoted. You’re correct that the player promoted this year was new to the club and with the second team for only a short time. However the two starting center backs for the first team were each with BSC for multiple seasons before their respective promotions. One was there from the beginning and was promoted at U11. The other - you call her athletic and raw - came from outside the club, was originally placed on the third team at BSC, was later promoted to the second team and stayed there for over a year, and then was promoted to the first team for the U12 season.

I’m not trying to toe the party line - BSC has its share of problems, similar to other clubs - but it’s not accurate for you to say “there is no promotion from within.”  There is promotion, as I have shown you with the 07s.

If you instead want to claim “promotion is very difficult at BSC,” then I’d agree with you. Based on what I’ve seen, it appears a girl needs to be able to supplant an existing starter in order to be promoted from the second team to the first team. That’s hard to do. I’d guess it’s the same at other clubs, but I’ll admit that I don’t know that for sure. [/quote]

Do you agree or disagree with the inital post that started this? BSC has fluid transition between the clubs. It does not. We have been with the club and played with all the kids you quoted. 1. the kid who went up at U11 got screwed at tryouts. She should have been up. The 2nd did not play a full season on 2nd team but I would agree she is an example of fluidity in that she played up some before getting pulled up. Thats it. Nothing since they went 11 v 11 2 years ago. Not even a call up unless you count the kid that got demoted from 1 who played a bit up at start of season. THERE IS 0 FLUIDITY.  It is not a situation where they are working together as a club with 1 and 2 where some 2 players get moved up. Never happens[/quote]

You’re correct. It is not fluid. BSC has never been a club where second team practices with the first team. Few clubs do this in my experience, but BSC is not one of them.

However, girls from second team are given looks in practices with first team. With the 07s, there have been at least 5 girls on the second team who’ve attended more than 1 practice with first team since practices resumed in June. 1 of those girls was the player promoted mid-year, but 2 of the other 4 attended close to 10 practices. In other words, they were clearly being given a look by the coaches.

This has been true in prior years as well going back to when GB coached the top team. Multiple second team players have practiced at times with the first team. These were tryouts for those players, and some were not asked back after only a practice or two.

These examples are not “fluidity,” so you and I are in agreement there. But to be fair, girls from second team are given looks on the first team from time to time. Maybe not as much as players or parents would like, and maybe not as much as other clubs do it, but I don’t know that. [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics