Reply to "God has a plan"

Forum Index » Religion

Reply to ""God has a plan""

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]Maybe God does have a plan, it is just a very fucked up, shitty one?[/quote]

And your plan is to cruise forums that deal with religion and post banal and profane statements.[/quote]

And your plan is to post ad hominem statements when you are stumped?[/quote]

Stumped? Not in the least. Only a foolish person attempts to engage someone like yourself in meaningful debate. Your mind is closed and you apparently delight in drivebys.[/quote]

And a smart person engages in ad hominems instead?[/quote]

First...instead of a period at the end of my original sentence it should have been a question mark rendering it a rhetorical question.

I called what you posted banal....so lacking in originality as to be obvious and boring...that was my opinion of what you wrote.

Profane? Was there profanity in what you wrote?

Neither was ad hominem. What did you present that I would attempt to undermine? I didn't question or assail your character nor did I add anything about your personal traits. In other words, you didn't present anything that I would be attempting to render moot by shining a light on those things but rather what you wrote.

So, of the various forms of ad hominem, the most common of which is argumentum, I cannot find one that fits.[/quote]

So it was just an insult meant to close conversation.[/quote]

It wasn't written to insult.  It's your right to be insulted for being called out for your remarks just as it was my right to call you out. Nor was it done to close a conversation as no conversation had been engaged. See, a rhetorical question is one you ask without expectation of an answer therefore with no expectation of a conversation.

I'm not sure, and won't speculate, why you feel the need to demean/belittle the beliefs of others. You have the right to believe there is no God or to be angry with God and/or to disagree with others. And if in doing so someone wrote something demeaning or profane to you...I would call them out too.

With that I bid you adieu.[/quote]

You are know a lot about literature and English usage.

Keep in mind that you may be conversing with more than one person here and and also consider that there is something to learn from the conversation if you are the one who originally used the Hitler comment.  Really, whoever did that needed to know that it's not helpful and finding out on an anonymous message board might be the  least embarrassing way.

Some may believe that a person is better off unable to conceive than to possibly give birth to the next Hitler, but that person should know that most people would not find that at all comforting and would not want to hear that in any context, religious or not.[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics