Reply to Child getting pulled out for ESL help but isn’t an English language learner

Forum Index » Schools and Education General Discussion

Reply to "Child getting pulled out for ESL help but isn’t an English language learner"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]I think if you write on the intake form whether ‘any other languages are spoken at home’ then they evaluate the child for esl.   [/quote]

This is the answer. [/quote]

OP - Yes evaluate is fine, but if he passed the test then why the pullouts all year?[/quote]

Pullouts are a GOOD thing.  He's getting help with reading.

To quote a great movie,
"What's your damage, Heather?"[/quote]

Pullouts are BAD if the child doesn’t need them (and sometimes bad even if the child is behind in the subject). [/quote]

And the term "pullout" suggests the student is missing some instruction in the gen ed classroom. Our only pullouts occur during scheduled small group time where every student works with a teacher on their level. All students receive tier 1 instruction as a whole group in math, ELA, phonics, writing, science/social studies. [/quote]

… first of all, it is definitely not true that pullouts only happen during “small group” time. Schools are under no obligation to coordinate like that to minimize loss of instruction time and in my experience, they don’t.

Second of all, if the kid does not need ESL, then an ESL small group is not on their level. [/quote]

In my district it is a policy not to remove students from content area classes except for level 1 newcomers during ELA. Most ESOL teachers pull students from the personalized learning time for instruction so they don’t miss any content. [/quote]

This is backwards. Then how do they learn the content if they are ESL? And what are they missing in the personalized time if they don’t need ESL but you are pulling them? [/quote]

How do they learn the content? Their classroom teachers implement the supports indicated on their accommodations/modifications form. Some examples from kindergarten are repeated directions, pre-teaching vocabulary, small group teaching, preferential seating, etc. ESOL teachers also do push-in during content time for support.

Personalized learning time is when every student works on what they need. Some students are retaught concepts or skills they missed on recent assessments, some are pulled for GAL (gifted and advanced learners) projects, some receive their pull out services on their IEP. I only pull ESOL students during this time and I usually pull the few students who need a lot more support. Most students get what they need from the small group time early in the day. [/quote]

Again - a child with NO ESOL NEEDS by definition does not need the ESOL pullouts in whatever context that happens - small group time, individual learning or actual pullouts. They should be doing exactly what a similarly situated white/American kid would be doing during that time. [/quote]

Fine by me but if your kid needs extra help, they most likely won't get it from the classroom teacher. The classroom teachers' small groups tend to be the on and above grade level groups. The ESOL teacher, special ed teacher and interventionist (who isn't an actual teacher, just paid by the hour to follow a scripted program) are the ones who do the below grade level small groups. [/quote]

Why are parents finding out about these "below grade level small groups" months and months later from their kids?[/quote]

We send home DIBELS scores three times per year with a letter explaining that students will be working in small groups on targeted skills. No idea how many parents read the letter and look at the results. I’ve never had a parent complain about their kid getting the extra help they need. [/quote]

So you don't inform parents when their child is reading below grade level?[/quote]

??? We send home the scores which lets parents know whether their child is below, on, or above grade level. [/quote]

The DIBELS reports I've seen do not use that language and it doesn't match up with what the report card says (e.g. Says a child "needs support" while report card says they are on level). It is super confusing.[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics