Reply to The Dropout on Hulu (Elizabeth Holmes story)

Forum Index » Entertainment and Pop Culture

Reply to "The Dropout on Hulu (Elizabeth Holmes story)"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]OK but did Elizabeth have a scientific concept to support the ability to do this?

Anything more than- wouldn't it be cool if it was one drop of a blood into a machine that super analyzed it immediately?

If Siemens could shrink and speed up their machines, they would have. What was the breakthough she was bringing to the table?

I feel like my 9 year old could come up with the concept. I realize I'm being snarky here but really I'm totally ignorant about all of this I just don't get it.[/quote]

I had the same thought about this being elizabeth’s “invention” in the same way 9 year olds “invent” magnetic levitating shoes or whatever. [/quote]

Even though I'm horrified by what she did, I don't agree. Sometimes inventions really do start by someone saying, in an almost childlike way, "what if there was a better way to do this?" Like the telephone or the internet also probably sound like the fantasies of a 9 year old at some time.

My issue with her is that once she had the idea, she talked to experts who told her it wasn't possible, and she very arrogantly didn't listen. If your 9 year old came up with this idea you might even think "hey, yeah, that would be great -- having your blood drawn is awful." But if you decided to pursue it, you'd talk to people who understand blood testing and if every single one of them told you "sounds great, people have tried, it's just very difficult/impossible to run most of these common blood tests on less than a certain amount of blood" would you then pitch it to venture capital and falsify a prototype result in order to start a multi-billion dollar company? No.

It's not the "having an idea" part that is upsetting. It's all the other stuff. Lots of people have good ideas they can't get off the ground. That's... most ideas.[/quote]

Right that’s what I mean/she had an idea that might have been viable (like magnet shoes) but it turned out it wasn’t snd she acted (as did her ridiculous board) like she was Leonardo da Vinci meets Alexander graham bell [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics