Reply to Anyone think we might be better off without Home Rule in DC?

Forum Index » Metropolitan DC Local Politics

Reply to "Anyone think we might be better off without Home Rule in DC?"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]I’m super liberal but if offered a tax haven status I’d give up Home Rule in a second. Would hope clean streets and corruptless government would be part of the package.  [/quote]

Taxation without representation.  
This is what the original Boston Tea Party was all about.

Pick one.  Either give us representation or waive federal taxes for us.
[/quote]

You have a vote at the federal level.  You vote for president same as every other citizen.  You are a city, and you have city representation in your D.C. city council.  Where is this taxation your taxation without representation?  Do you mean you want to add 2 more D senators and send more Ds to congress for political purposes?  Yes, I suspect that is the gist of your argument.  Be honest.   [/quote]

This is such a disingenuous argument.  People who live in DC DGAF about the power balance in sending two Dem senators to congress.  They just want the representation.  Party politics should not stop people from getting representation for how their tax dollars are spent.  [/quote]

+1 I want I senator I elected to call if I don’t like what congress is doing with my tax dollars.  I want a *voting* congressional rep to represent my interests.  If MD would take us back I’d be fine with that honestly, but I hear they don’t want us so I’ll take the tax exemption.  Or DC Statehood.  Either’s good with me.[/quote]

You knowingly chose to live in the only city in the entire U.S. without Senators.  People make compromises on where they live based on their priorities all the time, moving to the burbs for the schools, closer to a job for a shorter commute, closer to elderly family members or grandkids, etc.  If picking up the phone to call a senator was your top priority, you maybe should have compromised on a different location.  In your case, statistically, I suspect you are a D, and your senators would be Ds, so doubt you would actually be picking up the phone and doing much calling.  Plus, they don't really care anyway; they virtually all vote party line except the couple who have a lot of Rs back home to answer to.  [/quote]

I am not the PP you are quoting but I am the PP you are responding to. I was born and raised in DC and although I am a registered dem (because otherwise you get no vote in the primary) I lean right and would absolutely vote for an R senator if that person better represented my views. When I lived in another state for grad school I voted for an R senator who took the place of a D senator.

The “you can choose where to live” line is a super lazy argument. The fact that I could move out of DC doesn’t mean I should have to in order to have a say in how my tax dollars are spent. People who voted for Trump in the last election could choose to leave the US if they don’t like the president but that doesn’t mean they aren’t allowed to express their displeasure for Biden or vote against him. [/quote]

PP made such a dumb, and frankly, un-American argument with "you chose to live here."  If you had said that in Boston in December 1773 you would have been thrown into the bay along with the Tea. 
Please, get on the right side of history.  If you really want to deny people representation that badly then at least waive all federal taxes for DC residents.  [/quote]

You have representation.  Stop whining.  [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics