Reply to The elite private schools are getting rid of grades altogether.

Forum Index » Private & Independent Schools

Reply to "The elite private schools are getting rid of grades altogether."

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=pbraverman][quote=Anonymous]... this is a move to get rid of standardized metrics, that measure, well, merit....[/quote]

This is quite a statement. Not even the College Board contends that the SAT measures "merit."

Three years ago, when my daughter was just beginning a college search, an associate admission director at a "most-competitive" college made several comments downplaying their reliance on standardized tests. I asked during the Q&A, "You've spent some time explaining that standardized tests are not a primary criterion for admission. What information *do* you gain from SAT and ACT scores? What do those test scores tell you about applicants? In short, why do you require them?"

She was silent for a very long time — perhaps 15 seconds — before saying that she didn't really know. If an admission officer at a highly competitive school can't (or won't) tell us what she learns from standardized test results, I'm not sure what "merit" they're measuring.
[b]
Standardized tests provide a reasonably accurate measure of a specific skill set. [/b]I am not opposed to the tests per se; I am opposed to using them to draw conclusions beyond the skill set they assess effectively. I believe this is seldom discussed, in part because it is manifestly in the interest of test publishers to remain silent, allowing students and parents to interpret those scores in terms of "intelligence," "achievement," and "merit."[/quote]

Yes, it measures how well someone can take a standardized test. Not a really important metric to be successful in the real world.[/quote]

SAT scores do a good job of predicting basically any college success measure, even controlling for high school GPA.  Plenty of evidence out there but [url]https://www.ucop.edu/institutional-research-academic-planning/_files/sat-act-study-report.pdf[/url] is one, see fig 6.

People love to hate standardized tests but they are not bad.  They are quite good, and it would be weird if they were not.  Put it this way, it's an intellectual test that every kid in the country who cares about getting into a good college tries to do their best at.  So measures a blend of intelligence, effort, resources (yes), executive function, and I'm sure other things that, well, are we really going to be surprised predict lots of success measures?

But let's suppose for a moment that the SAT were a terrible test, testing, I don't know, basket weaving skill.  Given that it's the gateway to colleges, wouldn't you still expect the smartest, most driven kids to ace it?

BTW I would also expect athletic success to be pretty predictive of life success (if not academic success) again because the competition tends to select driven, organized, healthy people, again probably with family resources.[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics