Reply to DCPS students shafted again - sign petition to keep Jelleff field public

Forum Index » DC Public and Public Charter Schools

Reply to "DCPS students shafted again - sign petition to keep Jelleff field public"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]So only Maret students who are also DC residents should get to use the fields?[/quote]

Anyone can use the fields, when organizations haven't made arrangements for their use.  This is common.  My daughter's Stoddert soccer team has games at Jelleff; you can't use the field when they're playing, either.  The issue here is that many PPs believe that DCPS should have first call on the DPR fields, and should be able to force DPR to forgo lucrative arrangements that help everyone in DC (without offering similar compensation), because DCPS has failed in its responsibility to provide adequate facilities for its students.

Also, Maret is paying for the upkeep and improvement of the field.  What many of you are saying is that DPR (not DCPS) has to pay for that upkeep and improvement?  DCPS pays for DCPS fields; the arrangement many of you are suggesting would shift that responsibility to DPR.  [/quote]

Your argument is that DPR is responsible to all DC residents, not just DCPS students. So the non-DC residents at Maret should not have the same access as the DC residents at Maret. [/quote]

That's silly.  Maret is a DC entity.  It has rented the fields.  That's enough.

Stoddert has teams from Maryland - by this logic, and I'm being generous using that term, those teams shouldn't be permitted to practice or play on DPR (or DCPS) facilities.  [/quote]

No, Maret is a private school that has been allowed to purchase public facilities and block the public out of them, apparently completely. That's unacceptable in a city with scarce public space.  Green space should go #1 to the public schools and open recreation leagues.  [/quote]

Purchase?  No.  Block the public out completely?  Again, no.  They rented the fields for 10 hours a week, or so.

It's your position that all public schools (and I assume this includes charters?) have first crack at all DPR space?  And after that, "open" rec leagues?

OK, I guess.  those rec leagues have to pay to rent the space.  [b]Should DCPS?[/b]
  [/quote]

Sure.  The DC government can pay the DC government for use of the DC government’s field.  Works for me.[/quote]

I'm pretty sure it doesn't work for DCPS, though.

It isn't all just one pot of money.  I don't know, of course, but I'd bet that DCPS would strongly object to the notion that they have to pay market-rate rent to DPR for Jelleff.  [/quote]

DPR should prioritize the use of its facilities by DC taxpayers. Many Maret families do not pay DC taxes.  Those students should not have the use of DPR resources before DC taxpayers. [/quote]

How very Trump of you. Why should someones taxpayers status disqualify them from public resources?[/quote]

Huh?  Of course that matters.  If I take my family to a public pool in Md, we pay a fee.  Local public assets are for local residents primarily.[/quote]

All people/entities renting space from DPR, including Maret, pay a fee.  And Maret is a business in DC, unlike you using a public pool in MD.  [/quote]

Maret is not a business; it’s a non- profit and does not pay taxes.  Keep trying![/quote]

Paying taxes has nothing to do with it.  The point is that it is in DC, and is the party signing the contract with DPR.  That some kids don't live in DC doesn't matter in the slightest.  [/quote]

Of course it does.  DPR charges all out of state residents fees to use the pools for example.  YOu're doing some extraordinary mental gymnastics to justify this.[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics