Reply to Washington Post Contributor Believed Killed by Saudi Arabia

Forum Index » Political Discussion

Reply to "Washington Post Contributor Believed Killed by Saudi Arabia"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=jsteele][quote=Anonymous][quote=jsteele][quote=Anonymous][quote=jsteele][quote=Anonymous][quote=jsteele][quote=Anonymous][quote=jsteele]
You seem very eager to excuse this likely murder. The US has arrested American who spied for Israel. We didn’t chop them up into little pieces. Everyone should be outraged if this is what the Saudis did. That includes you. [/quote]

When did KSA promise to behave exactly like America?

On the outrage, leaving aside the very curious attempt to dictate the feelings to perfect strangers...Khashoggi excused the regime chopping the heads of its opponents who called for political reforms inside the country.  Now I am supposed to weep when HE got chopped up? Who kissed the royal bottom for years? Who ate from the hands of Al-Saud all his life? What's up with the clumsy attempt to package him as a lifelong reformer, instead of a lifelong government loyalist who either bet on the wrong prince or got too big for his britches?

Lie with the dogs, wake up with fleas. [/quote]

Most Americans oppose the death penalty for expressing views, regardless of how horrendous those views may be. I'm sorry that you are in the minority that believes otherwise.

[/quote]

Most Saudis probably don’t.  Geez, Jeff, how Eurocentric and imperialistic for you to impose your white American values on a totally different culture!  I thought you were a liberal  :lol: [/quote]

I'm happy to impose the value of free expression on anyone. But more to the point, I am an American posting on a website whose audience is 99 percent American. Khashoggi was a US resident and the US has an interest in his fate. I'm surprised to find Saudi apologists here.
[/quote]

I don't know if it's as much as Saudi apologists as pragmatism. The people you seem to allege as being apologists are the ones pointing out the badasses in the House of Saud and the risks of crossing paths with them. That doesn't sound like apologising for Saudi to me. Everyone on this thread seems to mutually agree that the Saudis are terrible.

I looked up Khashoggi and from what I can tell he fled Saudi in 2017. He might have been living in the US at various points but he was not American. He was firmly a Saudi. He knew the rules, as anyone who's lived in the Gulf would know. You do not badmouth your country or tribe or ruler or politics in public, and not in the way he did. All bets are off when you do so. Trying to claim the virtues of Western liberalism while still still keeping a foot firmly in the world of 15th century tribal politics is pushing it a bit too far.

I am not without sympathy over the potentially brutal death of a man, but as others have pointed out, he doubtlessly knew the risks and what he was doing. [/quote]

Posted from Doha. Another apologist.

[/quote]

I'm not quite sure what you're trying to imply with that comment.

Surely even you know that Saudi and Qatar are now embroiled in a bitter diplomatic situation that has Qatar embargoed by Saudi. There is no love among Qataris for Saudi and particularly the current Saudi leadership, who they blame as primarily responsible for the embargo which began with the intent of overthrowing the Qatari sheikh Hamad al Thani. So why would someone in Qatar be apologising or defending Saudi?

That aside, it is also very possible that someone may be currently in Qatar as an American expat with no particular stakes in the situation but merely an interested observer who likes to munch on popcorn while watching the local kingdoms and their tinpot kings and royal families squabble with each other over meaningless things. If it makes me an apologist to point out the dangers of allying yourself too closely with the local ruling families and what it requires of you and the potential outcomes if you are later seen to have betrayed that family, then so be it. [/quote]

Since you are the poster in question, you know exactly what your situation is. I won't imply anything, but say it explicitly. I think that you are beholden to one or more of the kingdoms for your paycheck and therefore have a financial motivation for defending the murder and dismemberment of a dissident. [/quote]

Well, I must say now I've seen it all.

I googled you and I see you're the owner of this website. I'm disappointed by your comment as it's unfounded and highly insulting. But it's your site. C'est la vie. [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics