Reply to Better teachers in poor schools-how?

Forum Index » Schools and Education General Discussion

Reply to "Better teachers in poor schools-how?"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]This rule is based on a false assumption:  That it all depends on the teachers.  I've taught in both--worked my tail off in the poor school.  Worked hard in the average school.  Guess which kids got better scores?[/quote]

No, the rule is not based on the idea that it all depends on the teachers. It's based on the idea that some of it depends on the teachers. Do you disagree with this idea?[/quote]

Yes and no. Lots of talented teachers give it their best effort, but there is burnout and still teh testing pressure (at least in DC).
The answer may be to incentivize. 
As with anything else in life, there needs to be incentives for anyone to take on and stay with a difficult task or any task that takes them away from their current gig. 
More money and the promise that test scores will not factor into their performance evaluations. Some sort of alternative measure of student progress: attendance, art work/portfolio, vocabulary building, mental health assessments, etc. 
Let's all be honest, lots of kids in our title 1 schools have very different needs that can be measured with an entirely different set of parameters. Set all that straight and then we can talk about test scores. [/quote]

I teach in a highly impacted HS.  I have the VERY high - as in those skimmed from the top who are indeed brilliant. I also have the other end - kids so damaged and with so few skills that nothing - short of a miracle - can bring them to grade level.  These kids are reading 7 to 8 grade levels behind.

One question I hear again and again with my low-level kids is "Why do we have to do so much work in class?"  I believe it, too, as most teachers with a load like mine burn out.  It's easier to show a movie or to pass out an easy worksheet than it is to stretch them/to challenge them.

I'm done after this year.

It's not worth it.  I care too much for my own kids and am resentful when I'm up planning and grading instead of spending time with them.

It's a terrible profession these days.  My children know NOT to enter education.  And if they do, they're on their own with college tuition, as it's a wasted degree.[/quote]

That's sad  :(

I'm in my 2nd year working in early childhood special ed. I taught for a couple years in general education before that.

Teaching is quickly becoming the degree that is not worth getting. I love my kids, and my job (on most days). But between tuition expenses, books, practicums/internships, student teaching, PRAXIS and other teaching tests it's an expensive degree. I had to pay a 450 dollar fee to my student teacher to student teach. PRAXIS tests are 100-200 dollars each, I've taken 6 so far.
Then you try to get a teaching job. Then oh that teaching job in that state requires more classes in that state which you pay for out of your own pocket (for me about 2,000/year for these classes). And more teacher qualification tests. Then your shelling out more money on supplies and working to help these kids. I don't think I'll ever get ahead of my debt and be able to buy a house or anything : /
I started a Gofundme with no hits...not that I expect a handout it's just been hard getting ahead...

On top of the financial worries, often times the kids are from very rough backgrounds or from spoiled backgrounds. Maybe this is primarily in the early grades but I spend a lot of time doing 'parenting' type skills-discipline, dealing with tantrums, brushing teeth, teaching them how to dress/undress themselves, do their shoes, follow simple directions, wash their hands, etc. It's exhausting and so much of it isn't because of disability, it's because there are no expectations at home. I have one student who will tantrum up to an hour screaming, cursing, throwing chairs, furniture...

On top of the money and the kids there's the bureaucracy of it all. Education is being run like a business and by people who know nothing about education and what actually works in the classroom.

I love my job, really! It's just whether the reward outweighs the costs...

Ok, rant over (today was a rough day)  :oops: [/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics