Reply to The bible says homosexuality is a sin, right?

Forum Index » Religion

Reply to "The bible says homosexuality is a sin, right? "

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]I'm happy to try, with two points made before starting. 1) I am not a fundamentalist Christian and 2) I have read your question several times and still am not completely sure of what you are asking, so apologies if I am off-base or incomplete here.

I think what I'm reading is this: You want to know why Christians say that many Old Testament "bannings" are now irrelevant to society and thus can be ignored in modern context, but homosexuality is not one of them. OT teachings forbidding homosexuality are still considered sin, even in modern age. Is that right?

The Bible is consistent throughout the OT and the NT that homosexuality is sin, even though Jesus Himself never discusses the topic. There are numerous versus in the NT that describe homosexuality as shameful, sinful, immoral, a wrongdoing, etc. The major difference is that the NT offers hope through Jesus Christ for those who are caught up in the bonds of homosexuality, actively practicing or not.

What am I missing from your question?[/quote]

That's a great start, thank you. If I understood you correctly, the answer is that the OT can be dismissed, but the NT cannot. But it is very clear that the NT was also subject to social norms that we consider to be outrageous now. (Slavery again.) Given that Christians accept that times and acceptable behaviors have changed, why not that one?

I will mention that I've only ever heard anyone quote Leviticus on the subject. And what kind of a world would this be if we tried to follow all of THOSE rules!?

You understand why it feels like mean-spirited cherry-picking, right? 
[/quote]

No, I did not say, nor do I believe, that Christians can dismiss the OT. While there are many differences in approach between the OT and the NT, the Bible is one collection of books with one consistent message throughout. It unfolds throughout history, just as mankind, history and his relationship with God develops, but the story is the same. The NT brings to life many of the prophecies of the OT, for example.

Remember that the OT was given to the nation of Israel, not to "Christians." It was designed to create with these people a relationship with God, show them how to worship HIm and attone for sin, and make the Israelites distinct from other nations as God's chosen people.  This OT law is not therefore "intended" for Christians of today. The death and resurection of Jesus took the place of that. But OT law remains a guidepost for how to love God and love your neighbor, even as yourself, as Jesus said to do. (E.g the 10 commandments). 9 of the 10 commandments are clearly repeated in the NT.

As for mean-spirited cherry picking on homosexuality, yes, absolutely, I understand how it can come across that way. And that is tragic. Homosexuality may be a sin in the eyes of Christians, but we know that we are all sinners, and that all of us only have hope through Jesus, no matter what particular sin may plague us individually.[/quote]

nice job of rationalization.  Are you a theologian?[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics