Reply to Burgundy Farm Country Day

Forum Index » Private & Independent Schools

Reply to "Burgundy Farm Country Day"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]OP, there are a couple of hard core Burgundy badgers who always pop up here. Yes, do a search; as you'll see, there are numerous strong opinions. That said I would not describe burgundy as "controversial"-- it is just a school that is not for everyone (well, no school is). The people who love it seem to really love it, and the people who hate it seem to really hate it.

...

So, what do I like and dislike? Pros (to me -- these might be cons to someone else): relaxed and nurturing atmosphere, warm teachers and staff, kids get a ton of outdoor time and independence, not rigid or driven by standardized testing, teachers are mostly dedicated and fantastic (though there are a handful I disliked), small classes, teachers are free to be flexible and creative and are not tied to a rigid schedule or curriculum, kids are nice to each other, school really works hard to nip cliquishness and bullying in the bud; good arts and drama programs, lovely campus, nice parents, friendly atmosphere and, as I said, the kids do well in exmissions.

Cons: a little on the disorganized side. Staff a bit uneven. Teacher and staff responsiveness varies. Language instruction is lame in the lower school. Instrumental program a bust. Extracurrics kind of random and uneven quality. Not actually very "progressive" in curriculum or teaching style (or at any rate, not clearly more so than many more "traditional" schools. They claim to offer differentiated learning but I've never truly seen this. Mixed-age classrooms (2/3 and 4/5) do not, in my view, work very well: even with two teachers they feel too chaotic.

Hope that helps!
[/quote]

And, OP, there likewise seem to be a few die-hard Burgundy fans who post regularly in response to every inquiry.  From what I've seen, they all say "Burgundy isn't for everyone, it's far from perfect, I myself have the following problems with the place [brief enumeration follows], but [insert subjective characteristic] about Burgundy is really fun!"

I'm not 20:58, but I think what 20:58 says is fair and certainly reflects, in part, our own miserable experiences with Burgundy.  The environment was downright strange, the academics seemed terribly weak, and while many of the kids went on to do extremely well in HS and college, a shocking number seemed to wind up in alternative/remedial programs.  I mean, like 1/4 seemed to wind up in community college, or in therapeutic HS programs, or the like.  The parents generally subscribed to an unquestioning group-orthodoxy about the place that inhibited asking even the most innocent question.  When we pulled, so did roughly 1/3 of our DC's class group.

[/quote]

Um-- exactly why would you characterize as a "die-hard fan" someone who says ""Burgundy isn't for everyone, it's far from perfect, I myself have the following problems with the place [brief enumeration follows], but [insert subjective characteristic] about Burgundy is really fun!"?  Seems to me that a die-hard fan says "it's all great." Noting that

a) it is not for everyone and things some people like will be off-putting to others; and  
b) even people who generally like it have some complaints

Doesn't seem all that booster-ish: it's just an honest response from someone actually trying to answer the OPs question.

And though yes, I have indeed posted this on previous threads, I will say once more: the claim that "a shocking number [of Burgundy grads] seemed to wind up in alternative/remedial programs.  I mean, like 1/4 seemed to wind up in community college, or in therapeutic HS programs, or the like" is verifiably false.

Burgundy was founded almost seventy years ago, so in that time I imagine it's had its ups and downs. But as a parent who has had kids there for seven years and who obsessively checks the high school and college lists every year, I can tell you that your statement is certainly false for this time period. Believe me, if your statement were true my kids would be long gone.  I don't know what combination of ignorance and malice would motivate such a statement, but OP, just call the school: they can provide you with lists of the high school and college destinations of any classes you choose to ask about, and you can judge for yourself.

[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics