Reply to We need to build more: gentrification caused by blocking housing construction (not the opposite!)

Forum Index » Metropolitan DC Local Politics

Reply to "We need to build more: gentrification caused by blocking housing construction (not the opposite!)"

Subject:

Emoticons





More smilies

Text Color: Font: Close Marks

[quote=Anonymous]https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2021/01/anti-growth-alliance-fueled-urban-gentrification/617525/

The Pandemic Disproved Urban Progressives’ Theory About Gentrification
The ‘gentrification-industrial complex’ isn’t who anti-growth progressives think it is.

[quote]The cause of the drop should hardly be surprising. The pandemic has radically [b]decreased demand[/b] for big-city living while also [b]increasing the quantity of available apartments. 
[/b]

Yet this basic fact, plain for all to see, flies in the face of much received wisdom about the factors that cause urban housing prices to go up or down. Among some leftists and liberals alike, as well as the politicians who court them, the idea that [b]developers of pricey apartments and condo buildings are to blame for high housing prices has long been an article of faith. In this telling, new luxury housing is the reason that former working- and middle-class neighborhoods in their cities have become fancy enclaves. [/b](“You know exactly what a gentrification building looks like,” read a recent viral tweet.) Fighting the construction of such housing would not only reverse the trend of unaffordability, but from the perspective of politicians and activists would also demonstrate support for working-class residents in the process. Since the spring, the pandemic has prompted a steady flow of stories about how urban life will change forever. But COVID-19’s most lasting impact on cities might be in helping put to rest this most persistent of myths about the relationship between housing supply, the cost of living, and that four-letter word of urban politics: gentrification. Not only is it a [b]simplistic analysis that absolves nearly anyone who isn’t a developer of responsibility for the problem[/b], but in portraying new housing as the proximate cause of gentrification it exacerbates the very housing crisis it seeks to solve.[/quote]

It's just supply and demand.  DC needs WAY. MORE. HOUSING.  We need to build a lot more.

And the reason we don't build more is that zoning law makes it illegal to build more new housing.

What we need to do: upzone the whole city.  Allow pop-ups.  Stop historical districts from slowing down housing.  Allow replacing single-family-homes with 6-unit apartment buildings all over the city but especially in Ward 4.

Yes, that will make homeowners property values go down.  That's the core reason we have gentrification!  That's what NIMBYism IS.

Build more. Upzone. Or face a housing shortage and a city that's unaffordable for everyone except the very rich.

[/quote]

Options

	Disable HTML in this message
	Disable BB Code in this message
	Disable smilies in this message

Review message

Search Recent Topics Hottest Topics