Sure I wish they could re-open school safely but I think we’d be better served if they focused on improving DL given where we are really at right now rather than investing in these wacky and potentially hazardous F2F experiments. |
Of course older kids need social interaction, but I would argue that for very young kids, it's almost impossible to decouple social interaction from learning. Their brains differ from those of older children in what they're able to understand and manage online. I disagree that social interaction shouldn't be a priority right now, too; we NEED to figure out for which groups it's more vs. less important to have it in person and more vs. less able to get it in person vs. online. Frankly, I wish schools would prioritize social interaction over academics right now, since social interaction minimizes stress and improves immune function. If we're a pandemic and it's a crisis, then let's shift gears to what really matters. |
Kids need in-person social interaction. Elementary school kids, middle school kids, high school kids. And I don't know what your opinion is, but my opinion is that kids' needs are always a priority, including right now. |
You call them "wacky and potentially hazardous F2F experiments," I call them "school with modifications for coronavirus." |
I would argue that our children's health is the number one priority. |
Exactly, and our children require in-personal social interaction for their health. |
Agree. I thought my young ES child would not do well wearing a mask at camp, and it’s NBD when everyone is doing it. Also she’s pretty shy and I didn’t realize how much social interaction she was craving. It’s like I have a different kid after sending her last week. She is SO MUCH happier than she was before. It’s clear to me that for her, learning in person will be better than online, so if they go to use to offer the blended option, we will go for that. |
Well first of all, my 4th grader had a decent experience. Not amazing but good enough. He knows his fractions and decimals and he wrote 2 short essays. They did virtual reading groups too and responded to teachers recorded daily read alouds.
I have no doubt if we do this again, then work would be graded, which is a necessity. My school hasn't announced a final plan yet, but we may go DO due to my quirky kids needs (not a great time to be dealing with a sniffing tic for instance). |
For every kid like yours there are 3 others who have a chaotic home life or other obstacles that make DL impossible. They will not be grading. |
Mental Health and physical health and being at schools if the home love is chaotic and/or dangerous/abusive. |
It's a necessity for some kids, but a catastrophe for other kids. So, then what? |
It's absolutely NOT a necessity, especially not for elementary school kids. |
I don't have any faith that it will be better.
|
I agree in person social interaction once it can be done safely like when there's a vaccine but until then herding kids into overcrowded schools with poor ventilation seems like a bad idea. |
Says the person who doesn't understand that mental health is also health. |