Is Sabrina Carpenter the official replacement for Taylor Swift?

[Anonymous]

Neither of these artists define themselves through men. That's a shallow take on their work.

I don't see a need to pit them against each other, either.

They are mentor and mentee, but different artists altogether, both talented and popular.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Middle aged Swifties obsessively playing her songs so they become #1 isn’t a bonafide pop #1. Carpenter has bonafide #1 pop bangers. Swift is too old to be a relevant pop star. Pop stars are teens to around 27. Swift is like a Vegas act with a deep catalog of old songs everyone knows the words to.

😂😂 sure. Songs charting for 50+ weeks is due to middle-aged Moms in America. Wow when do they take care of their kids?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I’m failing to see how the 2 artists compare.

I tried to start a new thread about her album cover and Jeff closed it! Makes no sense!

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I’m failing to see how the 2 artists compare.

I tried to start a new thread about her album cover and Jeff closed it! Makes no sense!

And…?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Middle aged Swifties obsessively playing her songs so they become #1 isn’t a bonafide pop #1. Carpenter has bonafide #1 pop bangers. Swift is too old to be a relevant pop star. Pop stars are teens to around 27. Swift is like a Vegas act with a deep catalog of old songs everyone knows the words to.

😂😂 sure. Songs charting for 50+ weeks is due to middle-aged Moms in America. Wow when do they take care of their kids?

What’s the last hit song by Swift that everyone knew the words to because it was so wildly successful? Blank Space which was 10 years ago. All the other “hit records” since are astroturfed over-produced crap. She doesn’t have her fast ball. She’s just an aging and fading pop star who milks her existing rabid fan base.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:The biggest issue with Sabrina is she looks and acts like the kind of woman who will hook up with your man knowing he’s your man.

That’s fine when you’re young and your fan base is young, but as they age into their 30s and start having families (and many dealing with infidelity), that persona will age very poorly. In ten years, will people with young kids wants to watch concerts where she’s fellating a microphone? No.

Taylor’s music is timeless because it’s about heartbreak, young love, confidence as a woman, things we can relate to at any age.

Lol, yeah, she literally has a song about that called "Taste".

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Middle aged Swifties obsessively playing her songs so they become #1 isn’t a bonafide pop #1. Carpenter has bonafide #1 pop bangers. Swift is too old to be a relevant pop star. Pop stars are teens to around 27. Swift is like a Vegas act with a deep catalog of old songs everyone knows the words to.

😂😂 sure. Songs charting for 50+ weeks is due to middle-aged Moms in America. Wow when do they take care of their kids?

What’s the last hit song by Swift that everyone knew the words to because it was so wildly successful? Blank Space which was 10 years ago. All the other “hit records” since are astroturfed over-produced crap. She doesn’t have her fast ball. She’s just an aging and fading pop star who milks her existing rabid fan base.

Cruel Summer was 2023 and is listed in Rolling Stone's best songs of all time. Everybody knows all the lyrics to that song.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Middle aged Swifties obsessively playing her songs so they become #1 isn’t a bonafide pop #1. Carpenter has bonafide #1 pop bangers. Swift is too old to be a relevant pop star. Pop stars are teens to around 27. Swift is like a Vegas act with a deep catalog of old songs everyone knows the words to.

😂😂 sure. Songs charting for 50+ weeks is due to middle-aged Moms in America. Wow when do they take care of their kids?

What’s the last hit song by Swift that everyone knew the words to because it was so wildly successful? Blank Space which was 10 years ago. All the other “hit records” since are astroturfed over-produced crap. She doesn’t have her fast ball. She’s just an aging and fading pop star who milks her existing rabid fan base.

Cruel Summer was 2023 and is listed in Rolling Stone's best songs of all time. Everybody knows all the lyrics to that song.

lol. Cruel Summer was an 80s pop song and 90s cover, which bolsters the point she’s been desperate as hell for hit tracks for a decade and is reduced to recycled ideas and hopping on trendy bandwagons. She’s spent and lost her creative fast ball.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Middle aged Swifties obsessively playing her songs so they become #1 isn’t a bonafide pop #1. Carpenter has bonafide #1 pop bangers. Swift is too old to be a relevant pop star. Pop stars are teens to around 27. Swift is like a Vegas act with a deep catalog of old songs everyone knows the words to.

😂😂 sure. Songs charting for 50+ weeks is due to middle-aged Moms in America. Wow when do they take care of their kids?

What’s the last hit song by Swift that everyone knew the words to because it was so wildly successful? Blank Space which was 10 years ago. All the other “hit records” since are astroturfed over-produced crap. She doesn’t have her fast ball. She’s just an aging and fading pop star who milks her existing rabid fan base.

Cruel Summer was 2023 and is listed in Rolling Stone's best songs of all time. Everybody knows all the lyrics to that song.

lol. Cruel Summer was an 80s pop song and 90s cover, which bolsters the point she’s been desperate as hell for hit tracks for a decade and is reduced to recycled ideas and hopping on trendy bandwagons. She’s spent and lost her creative fast ball.

What are you talking about?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:The biggest issue with Sabrina is she looks and acts like the kind of woman who will hook up with your man knowing he’s your man.

That’s fine when you’re young and your fan base is young, but as they age into their 30s and start having families (and many dealing with infidelity), that persona will age very poorly. In ten years, will people with young kids wants to watch concerts where she’s fellating a microphone? No.

Taylor’s music is timeless because it’s about heartbreak, young love, confidence as a woman, things we can relate to at any age.

Lol, yeah, she literally has a song about that called "Taste".

And its what Olivia's De Ja Vu is about...

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Middle aged Swifties obsessively playing her songs so they become #1 isn’t a bonafide pop #1. Carpenter has bonafide #1 pop bangers. Swift is too old to be a relevant pop star. Pop stars are teens to around 27. Swift is like a Vegas act with a deep catalog of old songs everyone knows the words to.

😂😂 sure. Songs charting for 50+ weeks is due to middle-aged Moms in America. Wow when do they take care of their kids?

What’s the last hit song by Swift that everyone knew the words to because it was so wildly successful? Blank Space which was 10 years ago. All the other “hit records” since are astroturfed over-produced crap. She doesn’t have her fast ball. She’s just an aging and fading pop star who milks her existing rabid fan base.

Cruel Summer was 2023 and is listed in Rolling Stone's best songs of all time. Everybody knows all the lyrics to that song.

lol. Cruel Summer was an 80s pop song and 90s cover, which bolsters the point she’s been desperate as hell for hit tracks for a decade and is reduced to recycled ideas and hopping on trendy bandwagons. She’s spent and lost her creative fast ball.

What are you talking about?

They’re just delusional and likely jealous. Would love to hear the music they write LOL.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Middle aged Swifties obsessively playing her songs so they become #1 isn’t a bonafide pop #1. Carpenter has bonafide #1 pop bangers. Swift is too old to be a relevant pop star. Pop stars are teens to around 27. Swift is like a Vegas act with a deep catalog of old songs everyone knows the words to.

😂😂 sure. Songs charting for 50+ weeks is due to middle-aged Moms in America. Wow when do they take care of their kids?

What’s the last hit song by Swift that everyone knew the words to because it was so wildly successful? Blank Space which was 10 years ago. All the other “hit records” since are astroturfed over-produced crap. She doesn’t have her fast ball. She’s just an aging and fading pop star who milks her existing rabid fan base.

Cruel Summer was 2023 and is listed in Rolling Stone's best songs of all time. Everybody knows all the lyrics to that song.

lol. Cruel Summer was an 80s pop song and 90s cover, which bolsters the point she’s been desperate as hell for hit tracks for a decade and is reduced to recycled ideas and hopping on trendy bandwagons. She’s spent and lost her creative fast ball.

What are you talking about?

They’re just delusional and likely jealous. Would love to hear the music they write LOL.

They are nuts and old

I'm Gen X and remember the Bananarama Cruel Summer.

The Taylor Swift song only shares the name. Sorry to disappoint the rambling PP.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Middle aged Swifties obsessively playing her songs so they become #1 isn’t a bonafide pop #1. Carpenter has bonafide #1 pop bangers. Swift is too old to be a relevant pop star. Pop stars are teens to around 27. Swift is like a Vegas act with a deep catalog of old songs everyone knows the words to.

😂😂 sure. Songs charting for 50+ weeks is due to middle-aged Moms in America. Wow when do they take care of their kids?

What’s the last hit song by Swift that everyone knew the words to because it was so wildly successful? Blank Space which was 10 years ago. All the other “hit records” since are astroturfed over-produced crap. She doesn’t have her fast ball. She’s just an aging and fading pop star who milks her existing rabid fan base.

Cruel Summer was 2023 and is listed in Rolling Stone's best songs of all time. Everybody knows all the lyrics to that song.

lol. Cruel Summer was an 80s pop song and 90s cover, which bolsters the point she’s been desperate as hell for hit tracks for a decade and is reduced to recycled ideas and hopping on trendy bandwagons. She’s spent and lost her creative fast ball.

WTF
😳

Tell me you don’t know TS music at all without telling me you don’t know it.

[Anonymous]

She’s more similar to Britney than to Taylor. Taylor isn’t sexualized

[Anonymous]

I like her but I am over the sexualized cop op. Men are pigs! But I am still going to pander