Place to get a really good apple pie since Pie Sisters is gone

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:BTW - what did the Pie Sisters in? Over the years I heard decent reviews but always thought their location on M St was terribly inconvenient.

They had the worst location on M. Not sure when they closed. Maybe they weren’t doing as many events during covid?

[Anonymous]

OP, what was the verdict?

[Anonymous]

Amphora Bakery

[Anonymous]

Wegman's apple pie is good. Also, Mom's in Leesburg.

[Anonymous]

I’m late to this thread but Pie Gourmet in Vienna is very good and a little closer in than Mom’s.

[Anonymous]

Village Piemaker frozen pies at Harris Teeter and Aldi. REALLY good for frozen.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:OP, what was the verdict?

OP here. Giant Pie was a gloppy mess. I threw it out. I ordered pie from Henry's Sweet Retreat. The crust was very good and I liked the texture of the filling but it had waaayyyyy too much cinnamon. It was basically a cinnamon pie! I'm going to try Little Red Fox or Praline next. By Thanksgiving, I think we will be very sick of apple pie!

[Anonymous]

^^^^^^^ You should have ordered from Goldbelly.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:^^^^^^^ You should have ordered from Goldbelly.

Yes if you want to pay between $60-100 for one pie. That’s not including S&H

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:^^^^^^^ You should have ordered from Goldbelly.

Which pie from Goldbelly?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:OP, what was the verdict?

OP here. Giant Pie was a gloppy mess. I threw it out. I ordered pie from Henry's Sweet Retreat. The crust was very good and I liked the texture of the filling but it had waaayyyyy too much cinnamon. It was basically a cinnamon pie! I'm going to try Little Red Fox or Praline next. By Thanksgiving, I think we will be very sick of apple pie!

Thanks for the review, OP! Please let us know what you think of the versions from Little Red Fox and Praline. Thank you!

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:OP, what was the verdict?

OP here. Giant Pie was a gloppy mess. I threw it out. I ordered pie from Henry's Sweet Retreat. The crust was very good and I liked the texture of the filling but it had waaayyyyy too much cinnamon. It was basically a cinnamon pie! I'm going to try Little Red Fox or Praline next. By Thanksgiving, I think we will be very sick of apple pie!

Thanks for the review, OP! Please let us know what you think of the versions from Little Red Fox and Praline. Thank you!

Another fan of Praline here.

[Anonymous]

The apple tart from Stella's Bakery is excellent.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:OP, what was the verdict?

OP here. Giant Pie was a gloppy mess. I threw it out. I ordered pie from Henry's Sweet Retreat. The crust was very good and I liked the texture of the filling but it had waaayyyyy too much cinnamon. It was basically a cinnamon pie! I'm going to try Little Red Fox or Praline next. By Thanksgiving, I think we will be very sick of apple pie!

Why not just bake one, Princess? They're very easy to make and you won't have to suffer through too much cinnamon. The horrors.

[Anonymous]

I was all for ordering from one of these small businesses but.. damn they are pricey!
Pies are one of the easiest things to make - esp the filling.