give it a rest - no need to throw shade at the college athlete experience - attrition likely mirrors the drop rate for any club or group in college |
This statement "very few recruited athletes manage to stay on the team all four years" is nonsense. Attrition on the high academic D3 team that my oldest plays on is about one kid per year. On the other ones' Ivy team it's higher but the roster is larger, 2-3 kids per year. On my P4 D1 Lax team years ago it was less than 10%. It's higher now especially for P4 sports because of transfers and the portal but it's nothing like you are implying. |
| Our child was one of seven freshman recruits. By graduation all that remained was our child and one other recruit. |
Maybe it’s baseball, but I know three different baseball players that were dropped by the coach in the Fall. All were coerced into giving up their scholarship for the next semester with the coach telling them that they would support them in the transfer portal if they did so, but would make their lives a living hell if they didn’t and ensure they never played D1 baseball again. This was just to get the $$$s back for the Spring semester…not for multiple years as the scholarships were yearly. I assume all the revenue sports are far more cutthroat this way. |
They couldn’t get in on their own intelligence/academic performance/scores so it was a way for them to get into the school. Without the sport, they would have been rejected. |
that is not necessarily true but athletes on my daughters team either couldn't keep up with the expectations, got tired of the 6 day a week practices, got tired of the constant commitments to the sport, were just tired, wanted to be a "normal college student," etc... P4 D1 sport is a full time job. |
|
ED1 with coach support
D3 Probably only institutional need based aid but will cover enough of TCOA at top LAC so we are all in. DC plans to play for 4 years but is planning for an intense academic track so we will see. We are very excited about the school fit and academics and never gave D1 a second thought. |
All of this plus sick of injuries, transfers, etc . . |
Ditto. |
I guess that I would not be real surprised if it happens some places. After all, going to Cal Baptist or Abilene Christian to paly a sport is kinda meaningless. |
It was a D1 Virginia school. |
Explain yourself. |
| I am the invaluable experience poster. I did not bother responding with specifics to the nay-sayer. The benefits are huge. IYKYK. |
It's not just D1. D2 and D3 are, as well. My child is a D3 athlete (had a D1 offer and is so thankful they didn't take it) and it was a GRIND. Practices or games 6 days a week. Super early lifting. Film review. Individual sessions. Travel out of state (mine had at least 3). Athletic/rehab training. Missing classes and dealing with professors about that. "Team bonding." Mandatory Study hall. And that is on top of classes. Look, I like our coaches and team. But what we were told during recruiting was just words. They made assurances that were not kept. They made it seem like the Head Coach was super friendly and treated the kids like family (really, it's just the starters). Coaches have left (fine, that happens). And they do not GIVE TWO SH--- about mental health, no matter what the NCAA says. You either do it, do it well, and do it with no complaints, or nothing. My kid's team absolutely did not haze. So, not all do. Kid has not been home since summer, which was harder on them that I thought (and me too). And to put salt in the wound, D3 gives no athletic money. You're doing all of the above for the love of the game. So you better make sure that you do because it's great. But it's also awful.
One final thought: those who diminish what athletes contribute can suck it. These kids have leadership, time management, grit, smarts, etc. that NARPs don't in the same way. |
ED2 with coach support. Was pressured to do ED1 but we said we needed more time. 20k merit. Not tied to sport but I doubt dc would have received it otherwise LAC Dc wants to play all 4 years but you never know. Dc was shooting for d1 and did have some interest from patriot league d1 but opted for d3 ultimately and I think that was wise. |