Forum Index
»
Off-Topic
| I can't stand it when people confuse to, too, and two. The incorrect usage of your and you're and their, there, and they're is also a big pet peeve of mine! |
You are correct. |
We use a comma both before and after the word "like". I was, like, that is too awesome! |
Totes!
|
There are a few annoying exceptions, unfortunately. The basic set is historical figures with names like Jesus and Moses. It is Jesus' teachings, not Jesus's teachings and Moses' deeds, not Moses's deeds. |
Actually, that's not quite the reason for the exception. If a proper noun ends in s, then the correct way to make it possessive is to add 's at the end. Gus -- Gus's book Wes -- Wes's steak James -- James's bike However, if the pronunciation of the word + 's is "very awkward", you can leave off the final s and just add the apostrophe. The tricky part is determining what sounds awkward and what sounds OK. Different style manuals draw the line at different places. Clearly one syllable names (Gus and Wes) do not sound awkward as possessives. (Gus's, Wes's) Two syllable names with only one, word final -s sound OK in the possessive form. (Janis -- Janis's bike; DIckens -- Dickens's novels) Two syllable words with TWO S or SH or Z sounds -- they start to sound a little awkward. Sometimes the word final s is omitted. Moses -- Moses's laws sounds a bit awkward. Some people write and say Moses' law. Jesus -- Jesus's mother. Some people prefer Jesus' mother. Three syllable words really sound awkward. Pericles -- Pericles's plays sounds awkward. It is usually written Pericles' plays. Hercules' tasks |
Holy crap. Are you really the OP who started lecturing strangers about apostrophes? Because you are WRONG, depending on which style manual you follow. The majority of written materials read every day follow AP (Associated Press) Style. And her is the rule: The AP recommends that possessives of proper names ending in "s" be formed by adding an apostrophe only (no extra "s"). Thus, in AP style, the possessive of Jones is Jones'. If you follow Chicago, you add the s. But really, most people follow AP - like every newspaper, magazine, website in this country. I really hope that you are not OP. |
Yes, this is right. |
http://www.jhsph.edu/publichealthnews/style_manual/a.html |
NO, it's not, according to AP Style. |
That's an absurd comment. By your own logic, the poster is also RIGHT, depending on which style manual she follows. And style is not a popularity contest. If it is, then anything goes, because it is the public, not pulishers, that would make the rules. |
No, she's not correct. And what the hell is a pulisher? |
| The Texas Law Review style manual follows the Chicago rule, not the AP. I believe there are other style sources for legal publications that also follow the Chicago rule. So who wins? The lawyers or the print media? |