Fairfax County Double Murder

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Really curious what their family dynamic was prior to the incident. It didn't seem like BB and JM were trying to hide their romance even before the murder...

yea i'm a neighbor who moved in a couple of months before this. i really thought the au pair was the mom at first because she'd be walking with the dude all lovey dovey and shit. they were definitely not hiding their relationship to others in public.

Would you be willing to speak with an investigative reporter anonymously?

I'm not the previous poster, but I've known BB for a long time; my tune has recently changed, and I'd be happy to chat

Do you know of anyone who honestly thinks he’s innocent? Like is there anyone out there who truly believes him?

His mother is pretending to believe him.

Well, that was revealed to be a farce when she told JPM snitches get stitches.

Especially after finding out the mom has been living there (not sure for how long but after the murders) so knew that BB and JM were sleeping in the same bedroom and together.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I’m confused about something. I thought the AP first said that when she came back to get lunches she saw a strange car in the driveway and then called BB.

Does the evidence now say (and is she saying) that she say the strange man arriving on the Ring camera and that’s what prompted her to return to the house and call BB?

That’s not the full picture, she was waiting in the neighborhood parked. She saw him drive-by and confirmed it on the ring camera, then called BB to say it’s time to get to the house.

The lunches story is made up.

They were lurking in wait.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I found it by looking at the news report on DC News Now. During the reporting they showed a couple of pages from the prosecution document on the video. You have to watch close and stop the action. I have no idea why the document has not been made available to the general public. See https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cNzLcN56oaU

Even on a laptop the document shown when BB is being perp walked is completely illegible to me. Thanks for details PP. Horrific crimes, and so completely pointless. So very sad.

this is what I got.


From 2:06
"
…possession of the large knife that Ryan had brought into the home. Fingerprint analysts found partial prints on the knife for which the defendant could not be excluded. Autopsy findings on Christine's body are consistent with her arms being pinned down while she was stabbed once through the left side of her neck.
An immobilized Christine instinctively and defensively could only turn her head away from this blow but this exposed the right side of her neck where she was then stabbed repeatedly, five more times. At 7:47, Peres Magalhaes who was in the bedroom as well, called 911. But, it would appear that this call was too soon for this defendant, given what he knew he still had to do, and that call was terminated after just 8 seconds without explanation. We know Peres Magathes was in that room when she made the call, and we know much of what had happened simply by listening to that call. The sound you will hear in the background is a wounded Joe Ryan, still alive and moaning in agony and despair

Within seconds, 911 operators called back to Peres Magalhaes' phone but for some unknown reason got no answer from the co-defendant. Fully 15 minutes would pass before the co-defendant made her second call. The analysis of the Forensic team of experts in this case explains what happened in that 15-minute timeframe. The Commonwealth's evidence will show that both Christine's and Joe Ryan's body were moved and repositioned in the room. Ryan's knapsack was repacked with the items he had brought to the house except that the knife was not. Instead, it was positioned on the floor a few feet from his and Christine's body. His arms were intentionally positioned across his body as if in a funeral pose and then smeared with Christine's blood. This finding. specifically, is confirmed by the actual smearing pattern present and the location of a second gunshot wound, which entered Ryan's chest in a downward angle from 7-8 feet away and was found only after paramedics lifted his left arm to reveal that bullet's entry wound. That shot was delivered by the co-defendant during that 15-minute gap and killed Joe Ryan, immediately, exploding and ….. his heart. We know this because she confessed to detectives later that day that the defendant instructed her to go to a safe in closet, retrieve the second 9mm handgun, the same one that he had….. month before, and return to the bedroom and shoot Ryan as he had every reason to discuss circumstances which supposedly brought him face to face with a home intruder who was in the process of killing his wife, Instead made only minimal statements at the scene save but a few off-the-cuff comments which were telling in and of themselves. In one, he claimed to first responders that the 15-minute gap between 911….."


From 2:24
"…later searched his car that day they found the egg McMuffin with but a single bite having been taken out of it during the entire 20 minutes of its existence.


Apparently, the defendant didn't have much of an appetite that morning.
White the defendant parked and waited at that MeDonaids, outside his residence, a few
doors down in the cut-de sac, his co-defendant had not left for the zoo with the chitd.
Instead, she was waiting, as well. She claimed to police that she had forgotten the childs lunch and was preparing to go back to the house when, at 7:30, os Ring camera footage showed, Joe Ryan pulled up to the Banfield's. Peres Megalhaes told detectives he parked his car in the driveway and entered the home carrying with him a bag. According to cell phone records and Peres Mogalhaes statements to detectives, she was supposedly fearful and uncertain so she called Christine's cellphone, but it went to voicemail. She then called the defendant’s phone and spoke with him. The defendant called his wife's phone, as well. But someone knew there would be no answer because Christine’s phone was not where one would expect, at her side as she slept, perhaps on the nightstand, but, instead, it had been turned off and strangely placed in a drawer just of the living room on the first floor of the house, where detectives would discover it later that morning. Ring camera footage shows the defendant returned to the house at 7:37. Upon his arrival. he, his co-defendant, and his daughter approached the house but, as his co-defendant explained to detectives, instead of entering through the front door, the defendant took them to the side of the house, through the gate of the fenced yard and around the back where they then made entry into the basement. The defendant and co-defendant gave the child her iPad and instructions to stay there. They secured her there as they locked o child's gate behind them as they then ascended the stairs to the first and then the second floor.

On August 16, 2024 Fairfax County Police received two definitive reports from expert
Forensic investigators who spent over a year reviewing photographs of the bedroom as a
appeared just after Christine and Joe were brutally murdered as well as extensive tangible
evidence and certificates of analysis related to blood DNA end fingerprints. Based on this
es of forensic science, along with inculpatory…
commonwealth will establish at trial the following…"

Where/how did you get a hold of the filings?

Read just upthread. The DC News Now video shows several of the exhibits from the Commonwealth with details that have not been made public previously. The exhibits were introduced at the hearing denying BB bond.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Really curious what their family dynamic was prior to the incident. It didn't seem like BB and JM were trying to hide their romance even before the murder...

yea i'm a neighbor who moved in a couple of months before this. i really thought the au pair was the mom at first because she'd be walking with the dude all lovey dovey and shit. they were definitely not hiding their relationship to others in public.

Would you be willing to speak with an investigative reporter anonymously?

I'm not the previous poster, but I've known BB for a long time; my tune has recently changed, and I'd be happy to chat

Do you know of anyone who honestly thinks he’s innocent? Like is there anyone out there who truly believes him?

His mother is pretending to believe him.

Well, that was revealed to be a farce when she told JPM snitches get stitches.

Especially after finding out the mom has been living there (not sure for how long but after the murders) so knew that BB and JM were sleeping in the same bedroom and together.

Apple did not fall far from the tree there. I look forward to her arrest for impeding an investigation. Trash humans all around.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:This was not a case where either victim died instantly. The horror and suffering over this time is sickening to contemplate. I still am not buying a gun in a safe in a closet, I think both defendants had the victims at gunpoint quickly.

Thanks for typing out the above, PP.

Just utter depravity and indifference to human life. With a CHILD in the home who then was forced to play happy familiy with her mommy's killers.

I am on the fence on whether she was sent to the closet to get the second gun or had it the whole time. I can see Brendan, as CB & JR lay dying (and his young accomplice maybe now scared and definitely in shock) suddenly deciding to make sure JPM keeps her mouth shut by making sure she is just as culpable as he is and directing her to take that shot.

I sort of agree, I was recently thinking that I’m not sure if the second shot/gun was in the original plan. I’m thinking that because of police/1st responder saying Brendan asked if Joe still had a pulse….I think after the first shot, he could have been worried Joe wouldn’t die and would tell what happened.

IMO it had to be part of the plan, gave her skin in the game to shut up. Why else take her to the range repeatedly and buy a second gun for her to use?

Pro hint, the bs about the gun being locked in the safe is just as fake as the lunches story.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:There has been considerable speculation in these pages; there is nothing wrong with that as long as it is made clear when it is nothing more than that. What is unfortunate is the speculation and arguments over things that are clear from the court records. For example, there was endless back and forth about "no signs of a struggle" as well as how this might show Christine was drugged. But here is what prosecutor's set forth in court papers:

"Autopsy findings on Christine’s body are consistent with her arms being pinned down while she was stabbed once through the left side of her neck. An immobilized Christine instinctively and defensively could only turn her head away from this blow but this exposed the right side of her neck where she was then stabbed repeatedly, five more times."

While that is not proof at this point, it does establish what the prosecution intends to show about the stabbing.

My biggest concern is that the case may not be the slam-dunk that many here are suggesting. If Magalhaes does not flip, in each separate case the prosecution will have to demonstrate that a particular act was either performed by a specific defendant or that it was part of a conspiracy between the two. Defense lawyers for each could claim that the other one was responsible. From what we have previously heard from her lawyer, that at least seemed to be the direction they were going. Hopefully, the lengthy, painstaking efforts of police and prosecutors have build an air-tight case but we cannot really say at this point.

After seeing the things Juliana wrote in the Nanny group I can totally see her holding Christine down while Brendan stabbed her to death. Sick sick sick.

What did she write in the Nanny group??

Read posts upthread.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Really curious what their family dynamic was prior to the incident. It didn't seem like BB and JM were trying to hide their romance even before the murder...

yea i'm a neighbor who moved in a couple of months before this. i really thought the au pair was the mom at first because she'd be walking with the dude all lovey dovey and shit. they were definitely not hiding their relationship to others in public.

Would you be willing to speak with an investigative reporter anonymously?

I'm not the previous poster, but I've known BB for a long time; my tune has recently changed, and I'd be happy to chat

Do you know of anyone who honestly thinks he’s innocent? Like is there anyone out there who truly believes him?

His mother is pretending to believe him.

Well, that was revealed to be a farce when she told JPM snitches get stitches.

This.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Really curious what their family dynamic was prior to the incident. It didn't seem like BB and JM were trying to hide their romance even before the murder...

yea i'm a neighbor who moved in a couple of months before this. i really thought the au pair was the mom at first because she'd be walking with the dude all lovey dovey and shit. they were definitely not hiding their relationship to others in public.

Would you be willing to speak with an investigative reporter anonymously?

I'm not the previous poster, but I've known BB for a long time; my tune has recently changed, and I'd be happy to chat

Do you know of anyone who honestly thinks he’s innocent? Like is there anyone out there who truly believes him?

His mother is pretending to believe him.

Well, that was revealed to be a farce when she told JPM snitches get stitches.

Especially after finding out the mom has been living there (not sure for how long but after the murders) so knew that BB and JM were sleeping in the same bedroom and together.

She apparently knew about his past affairs as well.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:This was not a case where either victim died instantly. The horror and suffering over this time is sickening to contemplate. I still am not buying a gun in a safe in a closet, I think both defendants had the victims at gunpoint quickly.

Thanks for typing out the above, PP.

Just utter depravity and indifference to human life. With a CHILD in the home who then was forced to play happy familiy with her mommy's killers.

I am on the fence on whether she was sent to the closet to get the second gun or had it the whole time. I can see Brendan, as CB & JR lay dying (and his young accomplice maybe now scared and definitely in shock) suddenly deciding to make sure JPM keeps her mouth shut by making sure she is just as culpable as he is and directing her to take that shot.

I sort of agree, I was recently thinking that I’m not sure if the second shot/gun was in the original plan. I’m thinking that because of police/1st responder saying Brendan asked if Joe still had a pulse….I think after the first shot, he could have been worried Joe wouldn’t die and would tell what happened.

IMO it had to be part of the plan, gave her skin in the game to shut up. Why else take her to the range repeatedly and buy a second gun for her to use?

Pro hint, the bs about the gun being locked in the safe is just as fake as the lunches story.

A few days ago I was firmly in the same camp. I pivoted because this theory pretty much requires that BB shoots JR such that JR is incapacitated, but requires a second shot.

There are plausible reasons BB took JM to the gun range.. it's a weird couples date.. there are plausible reasons that BB purchases the second firearm. IMO JM was still all in on the plan before the plan went to south. I just think she didn't plan to get her hands dirty.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:This was not a case where either victim died instantly. The horror and suffering over this time is sickening to contemplate. I still am not buying a gun in a safe in a closet, I think both defendants had the victims at gunpoint quickly.

Thanks for typing out the above, PP.

Just utter depravity and indifference to human life. With a CHILD in the home who then was forced to play happy familiy with her mommy's killers.

I am on the fence on whether she was sent to the closet to get the second gun or had it the whole time. I can see Brendan, as CB & JR lay dying (and his young accomplice maybe now scared and definitely in shock) suddenly deciding to make sure JPM keeps her mouth shut by making sure she is just as culpable as he is and directing her to take that shot.

I sort of agree, I was recently thinking that I’m not sure if the second shot/gun was in the original plan. I’m thinking that because of police/1st responder saying Brendan asked if Joe still had a pulse….I think after the first shot, he could have been worried Joe wouldn’t die and would tell what happened.

IMO it had to be part of the plan, gave her skin in the game to shut up. Why else take her to the range repeatedly and buy a second gun for her to use?

Pro hint, the bs about the gun being locked in the safe is just as fake as the lunches story.

A few days ago I was firmly in the same camp. I pivoted because this theory pretty much requires that BB shoots JR such that JR is incapacitated, but requires a second shot.

There are plausible reasons BB took JM to the gun range.. it's a weird couples date.. there are plausible reasons that BB purchases the second firearm. IMO JM was still all in on the plan before the plan went to south. I just think she didn't plan to get her hands dirty.

She held Christine down while BB stabbed her to death. There was no one else there so it had to be JPM. You are kidding yourself. That is way more visceral than shooting from a few feet away and CB was someone she KNEW. They went to the gun range multiple times in preparation for the double murders.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:This was not a case where either victim died instantly. The horror and suffering over this time is sickening to contemplate. I still am not buying a gun in a safe in a closet, I think both defendants had the victims at gunpoint quickly.

Thanks for typing out the above, PP.

Just utter depravity and indifference to human life. With a CHILD in the home who then was forced to play happy familiy with her mommy's killers.

I am on the fence on whether she was sent to the closet to get the second gun or had it the whole time. I can see Brendan, as CB & JR lay dying (and his young accomplice maybe now scared and definitely in shock) suddenly deciding to make sure JPM keeps her mouth shut by making sure she is just as culpable as he is and directing her to take that shot.

I sort of agree, I was recently thinking that I’m not sure if the second shot/gun was in the original plan. I’m thinking that because of police/1st responder saying Brendan asked if Joe still had a pulse….I think after the first shot, he could have been worried Joe wouldn’t die and would tell what happened.

IMO it had to be part of the plan, gave her skin in the game to shut up. Why else take her to the range repeatedly and buy a second gun for her to use?

Pro hint, the bs about the gun being locked in the safe is just as fake as the lunches story.

A few days ago I was firmly in the same camp. I pivoted because this theory pretty much requires that BB shoots JR such that JR is incapacitated, but requires a second shot.

There are plausible reasons BB took JM to the gun range.. it's a weird couples date.. there are plausible reasons that BB purchases the second firearm. IMO JM was still all in on the plan before the plan went to south. I just think she didn't plan to get her hands dirty.

She held Christine down while BB stabbed her to death. There was no one else there so it had to be JPM. You are kidding yourself. That is way more visceral than shooting from a few feet away and CB was someone she KNEW. They went to the gun range multiple times in preparation for the double murders.

I don’t think that’s the only way the knife attack of fb could go down.

I’m more confident with my assertion that one cannot shoot someone with a 9mm with a plan to not kill them.

[Anonymous]

That is the assertion of the Commonwealth based on forensics, read above. CB was held down and BB then stabbed her repeatedly on both sides of her neck. JR was dying on the floor, BB was stabbing, leaves JPM to restrain CB.

The killing of CB was up close and visceral.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:That is the assertion of the Commonwealth based on forensics, read above. CB was held down and BB then stabbed her repeatedly on both sides of her neck. JR was dying on the floor, BB was stabbing, leaves JPM to restrain CB.

The killing of CB was up close and visceral.

+1 the forensics show her arms were pinned down while she was stabbed on the left side of her neck, instinctively turned her head in response, then repeatedly stabbed 5 times on the right side of her neck. That is a two person job with likely BB doing the stabbing and JPM holding.

[Anonymous]

It's possible that CB was tied up as part of the sex game. If the idea was a scenario where JR was there for role play/pretending to assault and then threesome unfolds (if he was supposedly met with a couple before, that checks out that all agreed on the scene) then maybe she was tied up consensually by JR when he got there. That makes sense if she was found naked. It could have been a birthday gift to BB, if the marriage was struggling, and CB felt pushed into it (of course, BB and JM had bigger plans, and this was a means to an end). I think it's hard to imagine JM holding down CB on her own while being stabbed. She would fight for her life, and there would probably be marks of some kind on JM, and if this was a plot by BB then I don't think he would risk it not going to plan by depending on JM being strong enough to hold down CB. Maybe CB and JR expected BB to come in the room for the role play but once him and JM entered (and gun was pointed by BB at JR) it all went down - shot JR quickly, moved toward CB and stabbed her while she was restrained/in shock, JR still moving/making noises, then the second gun and shot comes into play, suspect JM already had it in her hand, so they both had guns to keep JR cornered when they walked in, and then she quickly shoots him (the second shot). Don't really know how to understand the delay in the calls - waiting until they were more sure JR was dead?

[Anonymous]

I suspect CB had no idea who he was or why he was there.