And why did the DOJ file the lawsuit? |
From the SCOTUS emergency filing... "...the district court below ordered Applicants, Virginia and its election officials, to place 1,600 SELF-IDENTIFIED NONCITIZENS back onto Virginia's rolls, in violation of Virginia law and common sense." |
Good question. I doubt Harris liked the optics of the Biden DOJ fighting for illegal voters and they should have known they would lose in appeal.. |
NVRA only applies to eligible voters. Keyword eligible. Non citizens are by definition not eligible voters therefore not subject to NVRA and can be removed at any time. |
No. The NVRA (52 USC 20501) only applies to eligible citizens. Read it. Don't take my word for it. |
| Who cares? What matters is how courts decide to handle the matter, not what is written. |
This just wrong. Here is what the NVRA says— “ A State shall complete, not later than 90 days prior to the date of a primary or general election for Federal office, any program the purpose of which is to systematically remove the names of ineligible voters from the official lists of eligible voters.” And the whole point of this provision and the DOJ lawsuit is that general programs that just do partial data matches like sweep citizens onto the list of purged registrations. Again just because one John Smith at one time was recorded as ineligible doesn’t mean that John Smith actually was ineligible (maybe like that Trump voter they were trying to avoid jury duty) doesn’t mean they are still ineligible (maybe they naturalized) and— most of all— doesn’t mean that every other John Smith in Virginia is ineligible. |
I read it— that’s not what it says. |
But that was a lie in the filing. They are not "self-identified non-citizens". Their citizenship was not verified or, if it was verified, it was not documented. As PP said above, if this was a legitimate issue, Virginia would have done this months ago. Youngkin intentionally waited until it was less than 90 days before the election to remove voters from the rolls. As with everything Republicans do, it is just a self-promotion stunt by Youngkin. |
Sure it does, section 6, 2. |
You’re wrong. NBCNews: “The state's plan flagged people for removal if they check a box on a Department of Motor Vehicles form declaring they are not a citizen or if they leave it blank.“ They were then given written notice to verify their citizenship within 14 days with their local registrar and those who did not do so were removed. |
Your last portion is wrong, this was a preexisting program. On the 90th day, Youngkin changed the updates to “daily” from monthly. Va Mercury: “The 2006 law directs DMV to send monthly lists of people who failed to identify as citizens to the state Board of Elections to be further forwarded to local registrars. Youngkin’s Aug. 7 executive order called for daily purges based on DMV data.“ |