Many people dislike US News because they think the methodology is bad. For those people, it has nothing to do with not liking where their college is ranked. |
T15 as defined above makes a lot of sense, even though it doesn't match US News every year. 15-25 you can argue about some of the candidates. Is Emory in or out of T25? UVa? Of course, Emory, UVa, and the other schools people argue about are all excellent. So in that sense it doesn't really matter. |
DP. The only people who grouse about USNWR are a tiny, tiny group who are obsessed with things like rankings. No one else cares. They look at USNWR for rankings and that's that. |
Not a single Public should be in the top 20. Need to swap out all three probably for LACs. |
|
The SLACs don't do well against the very top universities. But I'm not sure anyone at Pomona College wishes they were at Northwestern, Hopkins, Rice, Vanderbilt, or Chicago. |
SLACs have a very different objective and purpose. They are more focussed towards undergraduate teaching, if looking at undergraduate teaching, its best to look at following: https://www.usnews.com/best-colleges/rankings/undergrad-research-programs This has all National Univ and SLACs ranked together. |
Of course it does. The purported "bad" methodology knocked their (private) college down a tier, otherwise they wouldn't be bellyaching about it. |
Have you looked at the methodology? I did and wasn't impressed because it doesn't track what I think is important. (My school went up slightly btw.) |
Yes I did. The USNews methodology is fine. People will take from it what they want. |
USNWR obviously. ask any public or private collegd counselor |
|
Some of the faculty in the Pomona English Department might. |
Williams Amherst Swarthmore Pomona These are not universities |
https://www.usnews.com/best-colleges/emory-university-1564 Currently ranked 24 https://www.aronfrishberg.com/projects/usnehas historically been ranked higher than UVA for 30 years. |