
I mean, a couple of things: -she doesn't single-handedly control whether or not this happens, i.e. Mythical HS. -she's responding to her constituents, yes? I didn't think she was "at large" (but maybe I'm wrong and that would change my view some). |
LOL. It was classic School Board behavior. When no one was paying attention, they were talking big, at least to each other. So much so that they wouldn't let Strauss advance a Langley/McLean boundary change that actually would have added more kids and some housing diversity to Langley because they wanted to hold those two schools hostage to a bigger county-wide study. Which never happened, of course, because they got cold feet very fast. And then they were quiet as lambs when Tholen pushed through the smaller boundary change a few years later that increases the demographic gap between Langley and every other school, including McLean. At this point, Great Falls should be as supportive as anyone else of McLean's repeated cries for an addition, because without it there's always the possibility that the next School Board member will try to move more McLean kids to Langley and then they'd have all the same concerns again. But right now they are sitting pretty because the western HS is going nowhere, Centreville is getting a huge addition instead, and the next kids moved out of McLean will probably get sent to Falls Church, not Langley. |
No, of course not. There are plenty of other people besides those in western Great Falls who could have their own reasons for wanting to kill or further delay the western HS. It would be silly to suggest she's some type of invisible hand who pulls all the strings. She mostly only seems to have influence over a few things that other members don't care that much about. And she's been responsive to some of her constituents, just not the ones who actually most needed her advocacy. |
^ I apologize if this suggests in any way that decisions about a western HS should be based on what's in the interests of Langley or McLean. They should be based on what's in the interests of people in western Fairfax. It's just that there are a lot of spillover effects with any big decision and it's already affected the tone of prior discussions around a new school. To me, the fact that they've announced they plan to build Centreville out to 3000 kids is a huge signal that they'll keep finding reasons NOT to build a western HS, at least not for a long, long time. I hope they had conversations with people in that area to find out whether they want Centreville to be that large. When Centreville was originally built, it was designed as a 2000-student school. It's become common to expand schools to 2500 seats during school renovations, and some schools have even more seats now, but 3000 is really big. |
She theoretically represents 3 HS pyramids. Shhhh. |
At these large sizes, HSs land up with schools with in schoo with less overlapping populations. |
Expanding Centreville makes no sense. There is no new housing/developments in that area-it is built out and no one wants a 3000 kid high school. |
We are zoned for cvhs and i have not heard anything about expanding the school. Thats terrible for our centreville kids. No kids benefit from a 3000 kid school. Why are we punishing poor and middle class centreville kids to protect the property values in great falls and mclean? |
We also live in Centreville/zoned for Westfield. Our schools are already enormous. Is the community polled on whether they want a giant mega school? I certainly do NOT. Its already hard for kids to get leadership positions, play on sports teams, etc. |
I find it hard to believe the plan to build Centreville out to 3000 could have made its way into the draft 2024-28 CIP without Stella Pekarsky having been aware of it. So either she’s asleep and wasn’t asking the right questions or thinks it’s just fine. |
A new high school means county wide redistricting which is probably a horrifying thought for most of the board |
First, Chantilly is already at or over 3000 kids. And growing, especially as fewer Carson and RRMS kids go to Carson Second, Chantilly has the smallest footprint of any HS in the County. There is literally no place to build it out. It’s also a modular building, which apparently also is an issue. It’s not inThe CIP because the school is in decent shape and it cannot be expanded in any real way on the property they have. |
Chantilly is slightly over 2900 kids, not 3000. I assume you mean it's growing as fewer Carson and Rocky Run kids go to TJ now (not Carson). Not sure what you mean when you say Chantilly has the smallest footprint of any HS in the county. It has substantially more acreage than Justice and Lewis and about the same acreage as Centreville. So if Centreville is getting built out, it appears they could replace the current 14-classroom modular at Chantilly with an addition. However, it appears the plan is to expand Centreville, which again has about the same "footprint" as Chantilly, to 3000 seats, move some Chantilly kids to Centreville, and continue to leave Chantilly very big (though perhaps not quite as big) with a long-term modular. That's not what was envisioned when people talked about a new western HS, but it's probably what the community is looking at. |
On any issue, someone is going to be unhappy. That doesn't mean she deserves the scorn being heaped on her. |
And? |