Doesn't matter what anyone thinks. Facts are facts. From Wikipedia: Historically, the South was defined as all states south of the 18th-century Mason–Dixon line, the Ohio River, and the 36°30′ parallel.[3] Within the South are different subregions such as the Southeast, South Central, Upper South, and Deep South. Maryland, Delaware, Washington, D.C., and Northern Virginia have become more culturally, economically, and politically aligned in certain aspects with the Northeastern United States and are sometimes identified as part of the Northeast or Mid-Atlantic.[4] The U.S. Census Bureau continues to define all four places as formally being in the South. |
There's no "formal" definition of what states are in what regions. The Census Bureau can define regions for it's purposes, but that doesn't make those regions "facts." That's not any of this works. |
Do you struggle with rigidity in general or just when it comes to the census?
Here is a reasonable grouping that makes sense to people who aren't working for the census bureau: New England (CT, RI, MA, NH) -- 9 2 MIT 3 Harvard 4 Yale 13 Brown 13 Dartmouth 36 BC 36 Tufts 42 BU 46 Northeastern Mid-Atlantic (MD, DC, PA, NJ, NY) -- 12 1 Princeton 7 Johns Hopkins 7 UPenn 12 Cornell 15 Columbia 20 Carnegie Mellon 24 Georgetown 32 NYU 42 Maryland 42 Rutgers 46 URochester 46 Lehigh South (VA, NC, TN, GA, FL, TX) -- 10 7 Duke 17 Vanderbilt 17 Rice 24 Emory 26 UVA 26 UNC 30 UF 30 UT Austin 32 GA Tech 46 UGeorgia Midwest (IN, IL, MI, MO, WI, OH) -- 9 6 UChicago 7 Northwestern 20 Notre Dame 20 UMich 20 WashU 36 UIUC 36 U Wisconsin 41 Ohio State 46 Perdue West (CA, WA) -- 10 4 Stanford 11 Caltech 15 UC Berkeley 17 UCLA 28 USC 29 UCSD 32 UC Davis 32 UC Irvine 40 UCSB 42 UWashington |
I'd add the Minnesota schools to the Midwest. |
Those enrollment numbers are skewed. Massive state schools like Michigan, Texas, Florida, UCLA, Rutgers, Georgia have nothing in common with the New England schools. That's why there should be a private school ranking and then the large, state schools. They have completely different missions. |
This is the top 50 list. |
Yes, the USNWR T50 is a mix of small (and medium) privates and XL publics. There are a million "rankings" - I'm sure you can find one that meets your needs. |
PP here. Do you struggle with facts and prefer to go by your own opinions?
Seriously, I do think your groupings make sense. |
| The federal reserve districts (since 1913) have been official grouping for far long than the current census groupings (1950). How about we go with those? Or maybe the original colonies vs everyone else? Facts are facts, right? |
|
From the Census Bureau's own website. The whole thing is interesting but let me call your attention to the second sentence
"The partition of the geographic regions of the United States goes back to the colonial period of American history. By the 18th century, New England, the Middle Atlantic, and the South were agreed to be the major sections of the Atlantic seaboard." https://www.census.gov/about/history/historical-censuses-and-surveys/census-programs-surveys/geography/regions-and-divisions.html |
Missing LACs |
Lots of rankings out there. This is usnwr national top 50. Which ranking combines both? |
Newer facts are more relevant, right? Like updated history accounts? |
|
"...Minnesota schools", "Missing SLACs"
Pay attention to the topic please. |
| California is on a different planet. |