There is nothing nonsensical about the post. You have merely decided that you value and prioritize open lunch and clubs meeting during lunch over the alternative. You do this even though research shows teens benefit from and need afterschool activities to thrive, grow and stay out of trouble. You do this even though you know that clubs meeting during lunch is wildly dependent on the number of teachers in any given school being willing to give up their lunch period to host such meetings. You do this even though clubs in general lack strong support and teacher engagement in clubs is low overall due to burnout and unrealistic workloads by MCPS. And lastly you do this, even though your kid likely already gets their afterschool or extracurricular needs met outside of the school day through sports or activities that you pay for and supplement. You have merely decided to center your comfort and preferences and needs over the needs of the vast majority of children. And that's fine. But just say that and stop calling people who point out the reality of the situation "nonsensical." |
County rec department, city of Rockville, city of Gaithersburg and many other places have affordable activities. They have low income waivers and scholarships too. |
|
At my school there's over 60 clubs that meet at lunch and the teachers love hosting them. The issue is that most of the clubs aren't really anything of substance. They are not like FCA, 4H, Key Club, etc. Instead it's Comic Book Club, Karaoke Club, Pokemon Card club and stuff of that nature.
There's very few civic minded clubs that actually do things and really just a lot that are rooms in the building to hang out in during lunch and maybe do a collective activity. Teachers love hosting those because all that's required is to sit in the room and make sure kids aren't left alone. |
| Retaliation on teachers for making reports on crime is real. We are not allowed to do our job and our union will never help us unless is a racial or discrimination issue. Crime and violence coverups are real. |
FWIW, I don't actually pay for my kids to do afterschool activities. They either go to their MCPS sports practice, or they come home and do their homework and chores. At any rate, I think this is something that is decided school by school and club by club, right? That seems to make sense to me. If there's a community that is absolutely crying out for more clubs after school, they can do that, assuming there are teachers willing to stay to host them. I think that already clubs have the ability to meet after school, if that works for the club members schedules and they can find a teacher sponsor that agrees to that. One of my kids ran a HS club that often had meetings after school because they needed longer blocks of time to prepare for competitions and it was REALLY HARD to find teachers willing and able to stay. A couple of times I had to take off work to go and sit in the classroom as an adult presence because their teacher sponsor couldn't stay due to her own childcare issues, but said they could meet if they had an MCPS-background-checked adult that would stay. If you are so obsessed with clubs meeting after school, maybe you could volunteer to host a club after school. Are you a scout leader, or do you engage in other volunteer activities that provide a safe space for kids to engage after school? There are lots and lots of such possibilities, but they need adults that are willing to step up and give their time. I do that -- do you? |
And there you have it. The "club lunch meetings" that people are fighting for really don't do much of substance. They are in fact clubs in name only and really just a space and excuse for kids to hang out during lunch. Which is fine. But that's not what clubs are supposed to do, especially since kids put their club experience on their college applications. |
Yes, I do give lots of my time to youth. But furthermore, given the fact that teachers can't or don't want to stay afterschool for clubs, I propose we get rid of school-based clubs altogether and recoup that money to either the department of recreation or another community-based nonprofit that will do that work with our kids. Teachers, understandably, don't have the capacity. So we have to stop pretending like that's going to change anytime soon because it won't. |
This is a staple of the Moran Mismanagement Mafia. |
Eh. Peter is just implementing the will of Taylor. He’s a tool, not the source of the toxicity. |