New Yorkers: Help me find a restaurant

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:peter luger if willing to do brooklyn but otherwise his former waiters have spawned a series of spinoffs that are in Manhattan. Ben and Jacks on 44th st is pretty good as is Wolfgang’s

But know you need cash for Luger’s!

Luger's is highly over-rated. Burnt, grizzly steak, mediocre atmosphere and a pain to get to. No thanks. I think the spinoffs are better.

lol. Yes, we get it. You didn’t like Peter Lugers. You didn’t need to post 3 times.

Peter Lugers is a classic NY restaurant and one that people from out of town like to say they’ve been to. And the steak is great. As far as being a pain to get to, that’s odd considering Williamsburg, the neighborhood closest to it is incredibly hip and interesting. A great place to have a drink afterwards. But yes, if op only wants to stay in Manhattan, it’s in Brooklyn.

I only posted one of the anti-Luger comments. So there are more than one of us. The steak is nasty. It is a very particular cut of meat that only some people like. And 60 year olds don't want to have drinks with loser Billysburg hipsters.

[Anonymous]

Just go with gramercy. That’s a very safe bet.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:peter luger if willing to do brooklyn but otherwise his former waiters have spawned a series of spinoffs that are in Manhattan. Ben and Jacks on 44th st is pretty good as is Wolfgang’s

But know you need cash for Luger’s!

Luger's is highly over-rated. Burnt, grizzly steak, mediocre atmosphere and a pain to get to. No thanks. I think the spinoffs are better.

lol. Yes, we get it. You didn’t like Peter Lugers. You didn’t need to post 3 times.

Peter Lugers is a classic NY restaurant and one that people from out of town like to say they’ve been to. And the steak is great. As far as being a pain to get to, that’s odd considering Williamsburg, the neighborhood closest to it is incredibly hip and interesting. A great place to have a drink afterwards. But yes, if op only wants to stay in Manhattan, it’s in Brooklyn.

I only posted one of the anti-Luger comments. So there are more than one of us. The steak is nasty. It is a very particular cut of meat that only some people like. And 60 year olds don't want to have drinks with loser Billysburg hipsters.

Right right. Just one comment.

[Anonymous]

Union Square Cafe
Old Homestead

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Are these foodies? Any restrictions? Steak eaters? Any particular part of town?

Not really.
No restrictions.
Steak eaters, but willing to branch out.
Midtown would be ideal, but other parts of town are OK.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Are these foodies? Any restrictions? Steak eaters? Any particular part of town?

Not really.
No restrictions.
Steak eaters, but willing to branch out.
Midtown would be ideal, but other parts of town are OK.

The Modern is worth looking at.
https://www.themodernnyc.com/

[Anonymous]

Smith and Wollensky. Good food. Classic atmosphere. Good location.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:peter luger if willing to do brooklyn but otherwise his former waiters have spawned a series of spinoffs that are in Manhattan. Ben and Jacks on 44th st is pretty good as is Wolfgang’s

But know you need cash for Luger’s!

Luger's is highly over-rated. Burnt, grizzly steak, mediocre atmosphere and a pain to get to. No thanks. I think the spinoffs are better.

lol. Yes, we get it. You didn’t like Peter Lugers. You didn’t need to post 3 times.

Peter Lugers is a classic NY restaurant and one that people from out of town like to say they’ve been to. And the steak is great. As far as being a pain to get to, that’s odd considering Williamsburg, the neighborhood closest to it is incredibly hip and interesting. A great place to have a drink afterwards. But yes, if op only wants to stay in Manhattan, it’s in Brooklyn.

I only posted one of the anti-Luger comments. So there are more than one of us. The steak is nasty. It is a very particular cut of meat that only some people like. And 60 year olds don't want to have drinks with loser Billysburg hipsters.

You sound so hateful and angry….its a restaurant recommendation it is not that deep. Did someone hurt you?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:peter luger if willing to do brooklyn but otherwise his former waiters have spawned a series of spinoffs that are in Manhattan. Ben and Jacks on 44th st is pretty good as is Wolfgang’s

But know you need cash for Luger’s!

Luger's is highly over-rated. Burnt, grizzly steak, mediocre atmosphere and a pain to get to. No thanks. I think the spinoffs are better.

lol. Yes, we get it. You didn’t like Peter Lugers. You didn’t need to post 3 times.

Peter Lugers is a classic NY restaurant and one that people from out of town like to say they’ve been to. And the steak is great. As far as being a pain to get to, that’s odd considering Williamsburg, the neighborhood closest to it is incredibly hip and interesting. A great place to have a drink afterwards. But yes, if op only wants to stay in Manhattan, it’s in Brooklyn.

I only posted one of the anti-Luger comments. So there are more than one of us. The steak is nasty. It is a very particular cut of meat that only some people like. And 60 year olds don't want to have drinks with loser Billysburg hipsters.

You sound so hateful and angry….its a restaurant recommendation it is not that deep. Did someone hurt you?

Are you a descendant of Peter Luger? Or just a pathetic Williamsburger who wants to suck more people into your ridiculous neighborhood.

Peter Luger only serves one very specific type of steak. Most other steakhouses serve a number of different types. If you are having an event and there are people who don't like the Luger cut, they are spending a fortune for something they don't even like so are SOL. People should be aware of this. There are many people who like this cut and more power to them.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:peter luger if willing to do brooklyn but otherwise his former waiters have spawned a series of spinoffs that are in Manhattan. Ben and Jacks on 44th st is pretty good as is Wolfgang’s

But know you need cash for Luger’s!

Luger's is highly over-rated. Burnt, grizzly steak, mediocre atmosphere and a pain to get to. No thanks. I think the spinoffs are better.

lol. Yes, we get it. You didn’t like Peter Lugers. You didn’t need to post 3 times.

Peter Lugers is a classic NY restaurant and one that people from out of town like to say they’ve been to. And the steak is great. As far as being a pain to get to, that’s odd considering Williamsburg, the neighborhood closest to it is incredibly hip and interesting. A great place to have a drink afterwards. But yes, if op only wants to stay in Manhattan, it’s in Brooklyn.

I only posted one of the anti-Luger comments. So there are more than one of us. The steak is nasty. It is a very particular cut of meat that only some people like. And 60 year olds don't want to have drinks with loser Billysburg hipsters.

What are you trying to say here? Obvi not a New Yorker

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:peter luger if willing to do brooklyn but otherwise his former waiters have spawned a series of spinoffs that are in Manhattan. Ben and Jacks on 44th st is pretty good as is Wolfgang’s

But know you need cash for Luger’s!

Luger's is highly over-rated. Burnt, grizzly steak, mediocre atmosphere and a pain to get to. No thanks. I think the spinoffs are better.

lol. Yes, we get it. You didn’t like Peter Lugers. You didn’t need to post 3 times.

Peter Lugers is a classic NY restaurant and one that people from out of town like to say they’ve been to. And the steak is great. As far as being a pain to get to, that’s odd considering Williamsburg, the neighborhood closest to it is incredibly hip and interesting. A great place to have a drink afterwards. But yes, if op only wants to stay in Manhattan, it’s in Brooklyn.

I only posted one of the anti-Luger comments. So there are more than one of us. The steak is nasty. It is a very particular cut of meat that only some people like. And 60 year olds don't want to have drinks with loser Billysburg hipsters.

You sound so hateful and angry….its a restaurant recommendation it is not that deep. Did someone hurt you?

Are you a descendant of Peter Luger? Or just a pathetic Williamsburger who wants to suck more people into your ridiculous neighborhood.

Peter Luger only serves one very specific type of steak. Most other steakhouses serve a number of different types. If you are having an event and there are people who don't like the Luger cut, they are spending a fortune for something they don't even like so are SOL. People should be aware of this. There are many people who like this cut and more power to them.

I’m not advocating OP go to PL but your hostility towards it and towards Williamsburg is nothing short of bizarre. You also seem to be trading in outdated lingo about the city. Do you even live here?

[Anonymous]

Via Carrotta

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:peter luger if willing to do brooklyn but otherwise his former waiters have spawned a series of spinoffs that are in Manhattan. Ben and Jacks on 44th st is pretty good as is Wolfgang’s

But know you need cash for Luger’s!

Luger's is highly over-rated. Burnt, grizzly steak, mediocre atmosphere and a pain to get to. No thanks. I think the spinoffs are better.

lol. Yes, we get it. You didn’t like Peter Lugers. You didn’t need to post 3 times.

Peter Lugers is a classic NY restaurant and one that people from out of town like to say they’ve been to. And the steak is great. As far as being a pain to get to, that’s odd considering Williamsburg, the neighborhood closest to it is incredibly hip and interesting. A great place to have a drink afterwards. But yes, if op only wants to stay in Manhattan, it’s in Brooklyn.

I only posted one of the anti-Luger comments. So there are more than one of us. The steak is nasty. It is a very particular cut of meat that only some people like. And 60 year olds don't want to have drinks with loser Billysburg hipsters.

You sound so hateful and angry….its a restaurant recommendation it is not that deep. Did someone hurt you?

Are you a descendant of Peter Luger? Or just a pathetic Williamsburger who wants to suck more people into your ridiculous neighborhood.

Peter Luger only serves one very specific type of steak. Most other steakhouses serve a number of different types. If you are having an event and there are people who don't like the Luger cut, they are spending a fortune for something they don't even like so are SOL. People should be aware of this. There are many people who like this cut and more power to them.

I’m not advocating OP go to PL but your hostility towards it and towards Williamsburg is nothing short of bizarre. You also seem to be trading in outdated lingo about the city. Do you even live here?

Ah yes. The tired old “do you even live here.” Meanwhile you live on the far reaches of Staten Island or in Canarsie and are the expert on NYC fine dining.

[Anonymous]

Would you both just stfu?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:peter luger if willing to do brooklyn but otherwise his former waiters have spawned a series of spinoffs that are in Manhattan. Ben and Jacks on 44th st is pretty good as is Wolfgang’s

But know you need cash for Luger’s!

They take debit cards now.