Any recourse for kids skipped on ladder for Divisionals?

Anonymous
Swimmer on our team didn't get their divisionals top pick, because the team wanted to accommodate a swimmer below them who can't swim anything else.

The passed-over swimmer could be moved to other events, but has a much lower seeding in those events and, like everyone, wanted to maximize chances at divisionals.

Coaches said they "felt bad" for kid below on roster, team reps wanted to expand opportunities for more kids to attend divisionals. They asked passed over kid parents to voluntarily move him to other event, they said no, but team reps did it anyhow. Both kids attend all practices, are year-round swimmers, swim all A meets and have parents who volunteer heavily, not that any of that should matter.
Anonymous
What do you mean, they asked the parents to voluntarily move him?

The coaches pick the divisionals entries. This is 100% their call as coaches.

Anonymous
Like any team sport you play where your coach tells you to.
Anonymous
Even at INDIVIDUAL year end events, with no team points attached? The kids' one chance to swim what they want, supposedly?

Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:Swimmer on our team didn't get their divisionals top pick, because the team wanted to accommodate a swimmer below them who can't swim anything else.

The passed-over swimmer could be moved to other events, but has a much lower seeding in those events and, like everyone, wanted to maximize chances at divisionals.

Coaches said they "felt bad" for kid below on roster, team reps wanted to expand opportunities for more kids to attend divisionals. They asked passed over kid parents to voluntarily move him to other event, they said no, but team reps did it anyhow. Both kids attend all practices, are year-round swimmers, swim all A meets and have parents who volunteer heavily, not that any of that should matter.


Join another team next year if you don’t like it.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:Even at INDIVIDUAL year end events, with no team points attached? The kids' one chance to swim what they want, supposedly?



If this is your kid’s one chance to swim this stroke, how did they get a time to qualify for divisionals?
Anonymous
B meets ....
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:B meets ....


So they had multiple chances to swim what they wanted?
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:Even at INDIVIDUAL year end events, with no team points attached? The kids' one chance to swim what they want, supposedly?



There are team points at the divisionals for MCSL.
Anonymous
This is an NVSL situation
Anonymous
OP - is this for NVSL or MCSL?
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:OP - is this for NVSL or MCSL?
[google]

NVSL
Anonymous
Sad post
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:This is an NVSL situation


I would be pretty upset, they asked and went against the families wishes anyway. What was the point in asking then? Makes it 5x worse. I’d be going to the coach. Kids work hard and earn their spots at NVSL divisional, it’s the swimmers (and their families depending on age) choice.
Anonymous
OP again, not my kid, but wondering if there is any NVSL complaint process for this.
post reply Forum Index » Swimming and Diving
Message Quick Reply
Go to: