Executive roles are not about skill or competence but about relationships with other executives, owners, and board members. It’s just social class filtering for the most part unless you are the founder (which still tends to run UMC and UC because of risk tolerance). |
I was a federal regulatory policy analyst. I got an MBA degree and switched to being a corporate generalist analyst. Over the years, I've been involved in marketing, competitor intelligence, market research, project management, and contracting. It all has skill commonalities with my early government work. Skill commonalities, not subject matter expertise. There's no direct connection between my former agency and the industry I'm in now. My agency had oversight over matters pertaining to every industry. At my corporate job, I have no contact or jurisdiction related to my former agency. In my company, I have worked with literally thousands of people including many new college grads and professionals at all stages of their career coming to my company for the first time. Been trained to do new jobs and trained others. In my opinion, there's a lot of pretending that white collar jobs are highly specialized. That's an emotional crutch. A few months of training can take people a long way. So...my secret was the MBA. But, although I enjoyed my degree and what I learned, very little of it was actually necessary to do my later corporate jobs. Just like undergrad isn't always directly relevant to a job. We live in an era where computers being able to find exact matches on paper leads to the belief that such matches are necessary for success. While I understand that paper matching is efficient, it's a stretch to say that a person who does not match has no valuable skills to offer. I've seen how recessions hit laid-off people and their families. I have seen people age 50+ move to take jobs. They get apartments in the new area until they decide to move permanently. |
You can be completely open to both 2 and 3 and do everything possible and still end up stuck at 1 anyway. Lots of people competing for Costco type jobs and lots of people with great experience open to moving all over. It's tough out there. |
Because, if I am following the thread correctly, you blithely told the story of a move in your 20s before you were established in what you do. To compare that in any way to what the OP’s DH is going through is tone deaf. |
I prefaced that by saying it's harder as you get older. But, those are the options. There are 25 yr olds who refuse to move to where the jobs are, too. Like I said, my parents moved to this country with 4 kids < 10 without knowing the language for better opportunities/jobs. Back then, there was no support services for immigrants or nonEnglish speakers. If people like that are able to do it, surely a well educated person who knows the language can move to a different city/state to get a job, right? It's done deaf for you to say that a well educated English speaker cannot move to a different city/state while probably telling coal miners that they should retrain and move to where the jobs are. Life can be tough, and sometimes you have to make tough choices. I've had this discussion recently with my 18 yr old. I would think you as an adult would know that better. |
Were your parents over 50 when they made this move and found jobs? |
In have no connections or relationships. I just know how to do a lot of things that companies need and willing to pay for. |
If you had kids in mcps high school or middle school, you would know that most teachers phone it in and have a side hustle. |
You are hung up on this coal miner business. When the real issue is age. Let me try it again. Whether you are a coal miner or a white collar professional, if you can’t find work, the advice to retrain and be open to geographic resettlement is both good and actionable. Whether you are a coal miner or a white collar professional, in your 50s, your choices are severely curtailed from people in their 20’s. Whether you are a coal miner or a white collar professional who has lost a job in your 50’s, being told about how someone moved in their 20’s for a job is completely irrelevant. Hope that helps! |
I'm a different poster and I too found your post to be ridiculous. Answer this one question: when was the last time you were "laid off" or "moved for a job"? It doesn't matter if your 55 NOW; it matters if you are 55 and laid off NOW. |
This. I work for a state gov’t and we’ve hired quite a few former feds. With paycuts—but they’ll able to rise through the ranks. Good healthcare and a decade will be enough for a small pension. |
I would love to hear what skills those are! |
| I haven't read all the posts but out of my 3 friends who used to work for USAID - one found a job managing an international fellowship program (based in Europe but with a DC office); one is starting a doctorate in public health in a different state; one found a job in global operations for a start-up on the West Coast. It's tricky though if your spouse has a stable job here and your kids are in middle/high school. All 3 of my friends are single. |
Grad school might be a good idea. I went in my 50s and started a new career at 60. |
Yes. |