hope for 42+ women: CCRM lone tree vs NYU langone
![[Post New]](/jforum/templates/default/images/icon_minipost_new.gif){kind=icon}
Anonymous
|
Hi, ladies:
I would like to hear your thoughts on the clinic choice for my next IVF. I just did one IVF with Janelle Luk at Generation Next in NYC, which was a complete failure. Out of 13 eggs retrieved, only 3 got fertilized. Yeah. We did receive ICSI at her lab. No viable embryo after PGTA. Dr Luk didn't do any follow-up after egg retrieval, knowing that I would transfer anyway after this round. My question is whether I should go to CCRM lone tree in Colorado or pick NYU Langone. I scheduled to see Dr Jennifer Blakemore at NYU Langone in April and I have also consulted Dr Jason Franasiak at RMA New Jersy. From SART, these two clinics seem to be at the similar levels of IVF treatments. CCRM lone tree has the best statistics for 42+ women, but I didn't hear anybody talking about their personal experience there. I also checked out the local CCRM branch in Vienna, Dr Ann Martini said that they would do the same things as CCRM lone tree and has the same lab protocol (though I couldn't see that from their statistics in 2019 on SART). So where to go? CCRM lone tree or NYU Langone for Dr Blakemore for a woman with more advanced age (42+)? Could anybody share your experiences with CCRM lone tree, NYU langone or CCRM in Vienna? Many many thanks! |
Anonymous
|
NYU Langone!
(The Lone Tree clinic is a scam.) -triplet mom |
Anonymous
May I know a bit of your IVF experience? Did you go to either one or both? How was it? Thanks a lot. |
Anonymous
| i'm a patient at CCRM NOVA and have had a good experience. The lab is supposed to be of the same quality as Lone Tree's. I do think the CCRM NOVA stats aren't great, but they also take on a lot of the more challenging cases and become the second stop to women who have had failure elsewhere. I can't speak to CCRM Lone Tree vs. NYU Langone, but I personally find IVF hard enough without adding in having to travel out of state to a clinic. |
Anonymous
Thanks a lot for your input. I like Dr Martini at CCRM NOVA. She is attentive. May I know your age group and IVF results? And what IVF medicine protocol did you use at CCRM NOVA? Thanks. |
Anonymous
| Why not Cornell? I'd at least get a consult there before you decide |
Anonymous
|
NYU!! We also saw Dr Blakemore and she gave us our baby at 38. She's the most incredible person/Dr we've ever met and we feel so incredibly lucky that we were able to do this with her.
I can share more but everything - the lab, the nurses, morning monitoring everything was seemless and everyone we encountered was so supportive of us. Dr Blakemore really cares and somehow treats her patients like they are the only one when she is incredibly busy. You would never know it. Unlike some other Drs at NYU she tries to be the one to see you as much as possible. For us, morning monitoring she always let us know which location she would be at or if she wasn't in that day and who we would be seeing instead. She was able to be at each one of our eff retrievals (the timing is tricky part of this was happenstance that we loved and appreciated) and we were able to time my transfer with her. She also calls with big updates vs a nurse. And it doesn't matter if it's a holiday or weekend and she's not even on call. Besides being brilliant and a data nerd she is the kindest Dr and has the best bedside manner. She's always available to answer questions or for reassurance if needed. Trust her. She absolutely knows what she's doing and is up to date on the latest research. We can't wait to bring our baby in to meet her and go back for another transfer. We owe everything to Dr Jen |
Anonymous
NYU has slightly better sart stats and they have a slightly better lab. For what it's worth the facilities are also nicer and you have more access to people. We consulted at Cornell for MFI and ultimately ended up at NYU and feel great in our choice. |
Anonymous
can anybody post their egg retrieval or transfer protocol here?Also, where did you do your outside monitoring? Thanks. Below is a protocol I got from someone who got treatment at CCRM lone tree last year. Protocol 3 (Testosterone- Antagonist): Cycle day 1: start testosterone (1.0ml) to upper arm twice daily Cycle day 14: repeat CBC, CMP, testosterone levels Day 10 after LH surge, Estrace 2mg twice daily Day 11 after LH surge, begin Cetrotide/ganirelix, Estrace 2mg twice daily Day 12 after LH surge, begin Cetrotide/ganirelix, Estrace 2mg twice daily Day 13 after LH surge, begin Cetrotide/ganirelix, Estrace 2mg twice daily, last dose of testosterone gel Cycle day 1: last Estrace 2mg twice daily Cycle day 3: AM: menopur 2 vials, PM: 225 Gonal-F +Dex + Omnitrope 0.35ml AM: menopur 2 vials, PM: 225 Gonal-F +Dex + Omnitrope 0.35ml AM: menopur 2 vials, PM:150 Gonal-F +Dex + Omnitrope 0.35ml AM: menopur 2 vials, PM: 150 Gonal-F +Dex + Omnitrope 0.35ml Then ganirelix/ cetrotide Tentative trigger injection (Novarel/Pregnyl and Lupron) Tentative retrieval date (doxycycline after retrieval) |
Anonymous
| I'm the PP who is at CCRM NOVA. We've changed my retrieval and transfer protocol each time. If you're at a good clinic, egg retrieval protocols are very personalized. Whether you prime or don't prime, how long you prime, what you use to prime, the dosages of the meds, which meds you use, how you trigger, etc., are all going to vary. Just as an example, the protocol you pasted in from CCRM Lonetree above is not standard and is not at all similar to what I did. |
Anonymous
| CCRM lone tree is amazing. I had had success at columbia at a much younger age and then a lot of failures. Before Columbia I had a disastrous experience at SGF. At 42 we decided to give it one more shot at CCRM Lone Tree. I had the absolute best results as far as egg quality, egg retrieved, embryos, etc out of all of my cycles, including ones I had done ten years earlier. The care is a level above, and its a well oiled machine so easy to do a cycle in just a few visits. I did do my monitoring locally at CF. We transferred just one and it was successful. Everything there is a notch above any local clinic. I did look at cornell but it didn't have quite as good stats for 40+ at the time, and they also didn't seem to be such a machine w/ out of state clients. Lone Tree makes it very easy. |
Anonymous
Thank you so much for your input!!! Your experience absolutely gave me so hope. What is CF short for? Very much appreciated! |
Anonymous
| I had a lot of success with miniIVF protocol. May be worth it. I only had 3 eggs at age 43 but resulted in identical twins. Good luck! |
Anonymous
Did you get PGTA ? Which clinic? New hope? Allcare Or legacy? |
Anonymous
New Hope. Did acupuncture in conjunction through the process. Last embryo worked. |