You are so full of it with your housing “units” weasel words. Prior generations had options for smaller HOUSES and houses a little further away. But now affordable homes means houses with extreme commutes OR condos. The land has increased in value, for a variety of reasons such as increased population, Wall Street investing in SFHs, baby boom generation aging in place, etc. it’s not because people want big fancy homes, it’s because they want houses because, outside of NYC, condos are a TERRIBLE investment, often times WORSE than renting. They want a property that will be a good long term investment without having to spend 4 hours a day on a super commute. It’s not about first time buyers “expectations” except a desire to not be screwed financially or never see their families or friends by driving forever. |
My DS graduated from college two years ago and has been living at home. He is currently looking to move out with a roommate this summer. They plan on renting an apartment. Almost all of my DS' friends who grew up in the DMV and are working in the DMV are all living at home saving money, but several are now starting to move out. His friends who moved here for work have all told him they think it's great that he's been able to save money for a couple of years. My DS started at $85K and is currently making $95K. He has a degree in Data Analytics and works for a government contractor.
In two years, my DS has maxed out his 401K and it is close to $50K. He has also saved over $50K - putting in a high savings account and the stock market. He is responsible for his own auto insurance and cell phone. We charge him a nominal amount for rent - basically what I'm spending on buying food for him. As far as house rules, we just ask that he be a respectful "roommate." He is responsible for his own laundry. He lets me know what nights he'll be home for dinner so I make sure I have enough for him to eat. He gives us an approximate time of when he'll be home - not because he has a curfew but I don't want to be up worrying that he's been in an accident when he hasn't gotten home. DS has not had a girlfriend since he's been home so we haven't had to deal with overnight guests. He has had good friends come over to watch sports and we give them lots of space. I know he really wants to have a party but he feels weird having casual friends come to "mommy and daddy's house." It's been great having him home but he needs to move out. He has built a really good nest egg and is really ready to finally be on his own. |
I’m a teacher and I won’t make $100k until 20 yrs (if I last that long; it’s not looking good). |
And do you understand that many students still need to borrow money just to go to community college? I’m a teacher and my DS would’ve had to take out loans to go to CC if my dad hadn’t died and left me some money. You can save money if you don’t make enough to save. |
As long as total borrowing does not exceed 1 year’s starting salary, then sure go to college. Otherwise, do not go to college because you are making a Terrible financial decision. |
No one having this problem was alive in 1950. Only some of their parents were. So what’s your point? In 1875, most houses didn’t have electricity or running water. Even many mansions had cisterns with a rudimentary pipe system but no flushing toilets. That would be another way to get construction costs down, but all these entitled Millennials want electricity AND running water. And internet. |
Gee Beav that’s swell. Not really. So a mid twenties guy has no dating no prospect of dating and you think that’s not stunted because he lives with his Mommy? |
When I moved to DC after graduation in 2010, I knew almost no one who had grown up in the DMV and had parents nearby to live with. Everyone had moved there from somewhere else. We also weren’t making 100k salaries, think less than half that. Somehow we all managed by living in group houses and not having cars (why a car in DC?)
The key for me and DH was not having student loans more than anything else and getting on the property ladder early, way before kids. |
Yes!! Actually I got my condo in a bank foreclosure and sold it for a big profit to buy first home. BTW savings is stupid in certain cases. My wives good friend a decent looking blonde good figure has a net worth of 10k when 26. She decided to invest the 10k into a share in a small dumpy tiny Hamptons house and all new clothes, make up. Her plan she has 16 weekends to marry rich. She met a trader on Wall Street week 6 got married and is a multi millionaire no pre nup. Saving sadly is stupid most young women. Men are stupid. Very stupid. The girl in shape, going on vacations driving a mustang convertible with great clothes with zero in bank a rich guy will take over a poorly dressed girl living at home taking the bus with $100k in the bank. And works me to want to marry rich look good!! Dumpy costs you money in long run when single. 100 percent of wife’s friends who were hot and went out when single married to multimillionaires. The savers all married deadbeat men who saw their pot of cash and worked like dogs all their lives. Look at Lauren Sanchez she has billion dollar boobs |
Gen-Xer here. Yes, that’s my question too! When I was in my 20’s I was dating different people and would be mortified to bring them back to my parents house to spend the night. My parents were also not so laid back to have me sleeping over at boy’s houses if I lived with them. So bye bye sex life I guess. I’m glad I didn’t miss out on that and also on the fun times living in DC with my friends from college. Those were some of the best years of my life which wouldn’t be quite so good if I lived with my folks! |
My parents literally up and moved to a rural area that I would never want to live (and has no high paying jobs) while I was in college. Remote jobs weren’t a thing back in the early oughts and even today with more flexibility new grad hires aren’t often being offered a six figure job with ability to work fully remote.
I just can’t believe OP actually woke up and typed these words straight from their @$s. Also many of the UMC DCUM types OP references are helping their kids with down payments. So this plan does nothing to help the people really struggling with housing. |
The late 40s/early 50s saw some of the smallest housing constructed. The average new house before and after that period was significantly bigger. Not as big as today, but using 1950 as some kind of ideal is misleading. The combination of the Great Depression, WWII and the baby boom saw a massive housing crunch and builders were building as fast as they could and pumped out as many of the smallest houses as they could. |
Haven’t read the whole thing but this idea only helps the children of UMC families that can already afford the DMV - not the young people (like myself and spouse and most I know) whose parents live in other parts of the country with minimal job prospects. We moved here in the early 2000s and lived in group houses but those don’t seem as widely available anymore. |
This 1000% In the 70s people lived in 3 bed/1 bath homes of 1000 sq ft. If lucky you had a 0.5 bath/powder room. Very few homes had a full 2nd bath. The kitchen was basic (not luxury) and so was the bathroom. People's expectations of what they need to live have changed. |
My kid lives with us and banks entire paycheck since the past few years. Has a SO since college and they are getting married soon.
No student debt (merit scholarships and parents paying), paid off car (present from dad), investment account (present from relatives), wedding (paid by parents), all household goods to start a household has been already accumulated - so all of that is a significant leg-up. We are Asian-Americans. We have followed this path for generations to create wealth and pass it on to the next generation. |