Toggle navigation
Toggle navigation
Home
DCUM Forums
Nanny Forums
Events
About DCUM
Advertising
Search
Recent Topics
Hottest Topics
FAQs and Guidelines
Privacy Policy
Your current identity is: Anonymous
Login
Preview
Subject:
Forum Index
»
Montgomery County Public Schools (MCPS)
Reply to "What does Chromebook use look like in your kid's elementary class?"
Subject:
Emoticons
More smilies
Text Color:
Default
Dark Red
Red
Orange
Brown
Yellow
Green
Olive
Cyan
Blue
Dark Blue
Violet
White
Black
Font:
Very Small
Small
Normal
Big
Giant
Close Marks
[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]Just so everyone has all the facts... Go Guardian not only allows teachers to monitor/track student Chromebook use-it also allows them to block certain sites at certain times (or always if needed) and customize by student, if needed. Additionally you can limit the number of tabs students can open up. I am a media specialist and we use the Chromebooks with the older grades for one research project a quarter. Occasionally we also use them in order to incorporate interactive tools such as Kahoot, padlet, and Nearpod into classroom lessons. We are reading and discussing books the majority of the time. There are plenty of teachers who know how to effectively implement instructional technology and ration independent use of computers to a reasonable degree. We go by the philosophy that technology is yet another tool in our teacher toolbox not a replacement for books and other instructional tools. Feel free to ask your child's teacher about their philosophy regarding Chromebooks and instructional technology in general. Hopefully it will be a productive conversation and you will find that they are being used very purposefully--if not feel free to discuss it with them or go to the principal if that avenue doesn't yield good results. But just complaining here in a blanket fashion, making sweeping generalizations about Chromebook use in MCPS schools, is not very productive. Both my ES children are in schools where they are used to good effect and truly boost classroom instruction. [/quote] This sounds so reasonable and I bought this line when our school announced it had gotten Chromebooks for even the second graders. Kids need to learn how to use technology, so I was in. Then reality. *Teachers use the time as a reward for finishing seat work, so kids anxiously rush and don’t pay attention to their work. *We got all these Chromebooks so we might as well use them, right? So now kids spend their “reading” time on myOn, which is mediocrity personified, but hey, it provides the administration with “data” so let’s love it no matter what. *Speed math programs like Xtra Math and Fast Math have become teacher tools for assessment in our school, despite the lack of any research that they benefit kids’ math skills and ignoring the profound performance anxiety fully 1/4 of my child’s class exhibits about these high pressure programs. But they provide such enticing data and analysis performance charts! *Instead of using their time to write or imagine, students spend their device time fooling with avatars, fancy fonts, lame clip art, and other things on which no lower-grader should be wasting their school time. *Since you are a media specialist, I’ll throw in this one - when my kids go to media, they often have a book “read” to them by a computer. Happens in class, too, to keep the kids occupied for a few minutes while the teacher catches a break. Don’t love it, but I understand. But in the school library?! I’m speechless (well... not really!). Discussions about this at our MCPS school, with teachers and principal, are like speaking to an uncomprehending brick wall. Clearly, I am stupid and troublesome for not understanding how critical and amazing data and persistent technology access are for my young kids (btw, I develop apps for a living). Most other parents think screens are fine, don’t have the interest or genuinely don’t have the time to care about it. (thank you, DCUM, for letting me know I am not entirely alone in thinking this is all insane). And these are generally great and experienced teachers. The principal is “embracing technology” and our school has lost several excellent staff members who couldn’t stand the assessment and data obsessed environment. Remaining teachers are forced to use the above programs whether they like them or not. Staff development time seems to be focused on analyzing performance data and learning how to use yet more digital programs (and then analyzing yet more data charts).[/quote] I am with you on the overuse of Chromebooks in some schools for math practice and the like. Data gathering is super important but we take it to a crazy level. I also feel that we need to be careful with giving free time on Chromebooks as a reward. It's a slippery slope. Hopefully these are some of the kinks/issues of the early phases of Chromebook use and teachers, admins, and parents can pull back, reflect, and improve upon our current use. It is a learning curve and I truly believe most teachers and media specialists have good intentions for the use of these devices. As for students having books read to them via computer vs. a teacher I am not a fan of this at all. I became a media specialist partly because of my interest in instructional technology but mainly because of my passion for reading books to children and matching books to readers. There is no greater joy than sharing good books with children and discussing these texts with them. I even like to go old school and use songs, felt boards, and puppets to supplement these stories. [/quote]
Options
Disable HTML in this message
Disable BB Code in this message
Disable smilies in this message
Review message
Search
Recent Topics
Hottest Topics