+1 |
I think probably “phone” in this case is short for social media.
IMO, it makes sense to avoid social media for as long as possible. But meanwhile a 12-year-old can get a smart phone with all the parental controls set up so that they can check their homework, play Spotify, check the weather or check a bus route, text their parents or friends, etc but not access social media or YouTube. Parents really need to take the time to figure out how to set up and manage parental controls before they hand a young tween their first phone. |
To me the real payoff came at 7 when DC started reading chapter books and became happily engrossed in them whenever there was downtime. If you can hold out for this, it's gold. You wind up with a kid who has an attention span and can be entertained without needing the constant stimulation/feedback of a tablet. Even if your kid isn't a huge reader, even if you don't live the books they read, even if it's graphic novels. It's all STILL better than a phone/tablet. But you need to be willing to stay strong through those preschool and early elementary years. Your reward starts in mid-elementary and just increases with time because the patience/attention span/self-entertaining skills increase. So even when your kid gets a phone in MS, they have the ability to not be glued to it. You can take it away. You can set limits at night and during homework and family time. And they won't flip out because they haven't spent the last decade training their brain to respond to a little screen in their hands 24/7. Btw, I've made a million parenting mistakes, y'all could rake me over the coals for so much. But this I am rightfully proud of because it worked and it was not easy. |
It’s actually common sense but people are so stupid they need to hear it from experts. Defending your choice to give your young kids phones because you can’t handle two seconds of ambiguity about where to pick them up is straight up weird. |
+1. And we need more academics weighing in on this because we need schools to get phones and tablets out of elementary schools, and since some parents will NEVER learn, we need education pedagogy to swing. That means I'll take all the Ivy league experts we can find to reinforce the extremely obvious idea that small children shouldn't be using personal screens because it's messing with their brain development (not just academics but social and emotional too). |
+1 million. There would be a real market for someone wanting to help adults get off their phones. I’d sign up in a heartbeat. |
+100 |
We successfully avoided screens for the most part until my oldest was 5. We had a weekly movie night, but that was pretty much it. She got an ipad on long plane trips or drives over 3 hours.
Then school gave her a laptop in K. She spends about 5 hours on it at school (we get a weekly screentime report) and then has "homework" on certain apps at night. I think schools have to keep kids on laptops because they don't differentiate classrooms enough. There are way too many levels for one teacher to teach, so they use the laptops instead. |
Same. I had to disable facebook because I liked to scroll. I need to disable inta too. Sometimes it's just too easy. |
Sure. And then you start the skirmishes where they figure out how to get around those restrictions, then you install some parental security app, then they figure out how to get around it, then... No thank you. I don't want to start a series of sneaky battles with my kid. |
Okay, you might change your mind about that one. |
Same here. This is why I really hate to ever give my kid a phone. It’s too addicting. |
This is news? I could have told you this, OP. |
I'm a child therapist who sees mostly kids with severe anxiety. Some stray thoughts:
1. Yes, wait as long as possible for phones, especially smart phones and social media. My kids are young but my policy will be no smart phone till they're 18 and can buy it themselves. Lots of parental education about why they are harmful, just like you discuss alcohol, drugs and pornography. 2. Tablet time isn't so black and white. The issue is the lack of interaction and emotional connection/learning. The idea that screens actually cause ADHD is a myth- there is a correlation between screen use and ADHD but it might be correlation vs causation, they just don't know. My kids have tablets but are only allowed to use them on airplanes and at home if they have already had outside time, done chores and played a physical game or done legos/puzzles. |
It seems obvious, yet the common person somehow does not get this. It is as if the common person present in America in 2024 lacks common sense. Have we fallen so far as a nation? |