Boxcar Children were my favorite growing up, but they definitely have gender role issues - the oldest brother is always going off to work for money while the oldest sister is cooking, cleaning, setting up the boxcar, and looking after Benny. |
If you want to read something together, and their attention span is long enough, I'd start with Harry Potter. It's probably best for 2nd grade and up though. It does get dark pretty quickly, so if you read it before then, I'd pause for awhile before reading the other books. |
Wings of Fire
Sideways stories from wayside school Mrs. Piggle Wiggle Superfudge Upside down magic (such a sweet series!) Harry potter (#1-3 are light, then use your judgement) |
We enjoyed this too! What's not to love? The fact that it's a pretty short series and now I'm back to book #250 of The Rainbow Magic series and the same stupid plot with the goblin. Will definitely check out the Dory one. Great thread! |
Chapter-ish books with pictures
Dory Fantasmagory Bad Kitty Nate the Great Katie Woo Princess in Black Princess Pulverizer Graphic Novels Hilo Catwad Chapter books Wayside School series Stuey Lewis Harry Potter Where the mountain meets the moon |
Troll fail. |
There's a lot of value in older literature. We need to maintain a connection to the past. Their errors can be corrected by our improvements in those areas, and our blind spots (and culturally we definitely have blind spots) can definitely be corrected by the past. Our culture values diversity in so many areas, but not temporal diversity. That's a shame. That said, I really hated The Little Princess and The Secret Garden as a kid. They are both pretty trite books in my opinion. But my kids who in general read a lot of good lit love them, so OK. I tell them that those books (and other bad books) they like are kind of like cupcakes. Good for fun sometimes, but not for a steady diet. |
Some of these are really quite dark. Great books many of them, but not what I'd read with or hand to a first grader. My sixth grader? Absolutely. |
And that’s actually a completely FINE division of labor. |
Ok. That’s why some of them are noted as being dark. |
The Secret Garden is full of white supremacy, colonialism and bad attitudes towards people with disabilities. I wouldn't read it to any kid these days. |
So kids shouldn't know that those things happened? They shouldn't know that people thought that was totally OK, so they can realize that people can be total jerks? |
I think you read a different secret garden than i did. |
The writing is also generally better or at least uses more advanced vocabulary. It's great for kids to get exposed to reading like books like those. |
My Father's Dragon
Mr. Popper's Penguins |