This doesn't bother me, but I would talk to my kid about what he feels comfortable with. My kid hasn't dissected frogs yet, but they did dissect mollusks in 4th grade summer camp, which he found fascinating. My other kid is in 3rd and they didn't dissect, but they got to investigate a dead deer and the process decompensation which was gross (to me!) but he found it fascinating.
Anyway, this is one of those things where it depends on the kids. My kids would probably love it. Other kids would not. If you think your kid would not, I think its fine to opt out . |
https://navs.org/humane-alternatives-are-more-effective-than-harmful-animal-use/ |
My message didn't go through before. https://navs.org/humane-alternatives-are-more-effective-than-harmful-animal-use/ Children learn from adults. It does not depend on your child what he wants to do because he is too young to distinguish between what is right versus wrong. It is up to you as the parents to decide what values you want to inculcate in your child. If you want your child to learn respecting life no matter how big or small the life is, then that lesson starts at home, from you, and now. |
We did this in 5th grade. I wasn't traumatized by it, but I was grossed out. The thing I remember most about it was the strong smell of formaldehyde that the dead frogs were stored in - which stuck in my nostrils for about an hour afterwards. Disgusting, and I don' think anyone really found it much of a learning experience at 10-11yo. |
You’re a sad sack |
Am I the only one who had to dissect a fetal pig in 8th grade? Shudder. Didn't enjoy that activity. Also dissected a squid in 7th, a cow's eye at some point and the frog in high school. I knew medicine was not my calling at a very young age. |
I agree with this. I’m a biologist who opted out of dissecting until college. |
because people like you exist |
We dissected a starfish in elementary school and I don't recall being traumatized by it (and I say this as a life long vegetarian). |
+1 |
Totally agree. Poor animals. And what a jerk the teacher is. It's just a showing off type of thing. Look at what we're doing with our kids. Kids don't need to do that. |
I dissected a cat in high school AP Biology. I didn’t turn into a serial killer. Let the kid learn. |
Unnecessary killing is wrong. |
Why do you think dissection and learning about the world and the animals that live in it is unnecessary killing? Do you think ignorance is respectful? |
Yes. They sent us out in the wild to hunt down and kill cats. That was PE😁 |