Agree. I strongly disliked the age choice here. |
I missed it, but why was Tom hunted down and picked for the mission by Dickie’s parents |
While I agree that Andrew Scott seemed poorly cast at first, let’s talk about his excellent acting. His dialect was impressive being an Irish actor, and he had a stare that was psychotic and made you believe you were watching a madman. |
Andrew Scott is a genius actor. His talent is incredible. And he looks good for his age (I mean, I’d GLADLY hit that) but the black and white is a bit harsh on the skin at times. He is a bit old in the tooth for this role. And while I love Johnny Flynn, neither he nor Dakota Fanning look right or act right for these parts. I agree with the PP that the acting is kinda flat. There’s no “golden people” vibe here. And they aren’t selling me on why exactly Johnny wants to hang around with Tom, who is often kind of a pill in this version.
I’ve also read the books and love them as well as the Matt Damon movie. But my love for Andrew Scott goes way beyond those! |
Your ignorance is astounding. Women have been dressing as men for as long as there have been clothes. Gentleman Jack anyone? |
Agree with much of this. People like being able to root for a character and having a sociopathic murderer get away with it defies the standard narrative. None of the principal players come off all that well; they are unlikeable at best. Remember that the author of the Ripley books, Patricia Highsmith, was an uncloseted lesbian who travelled in international circles and likely knew a wide range of non-traditional, nonbinary individuals. It was just invented yesterday. The black detective seemed a bit out of place but it also worked on some level. Black & white filming does not work for everyone but I enjoyed the moodiness of it. They went in hard with close-ups of statuary and that became a bit trite. If that cat could talk. |
No. You couldn't possibly have read the books. A PP informed us that she was one of the *very few* who had read all of Highsmith's books. |
Has anyone seen Purple Noon? |
I agree he was terrific in this, he gave a very nuanced performance. However, when he was on screen with John Malkovich, he might as well have been invisible, JM has such enormous charisma, he completely stole those scenes. |
I have only watched through Episode Six but I don't understand all the references to Freddie as a woman and non-binary. Freddie is a young man with a slim build and somewhat adolescent mien who looks gay and somewhat effeminate but how is Freddie a woman cross-dressing as a man or non-binary? He looks like many young men in their late teens/early twenties who have not yet filled out in muscles, weight and bulk. Am I missing something? Are the police going to reveal that he was really a woman??? |
That’s Sting’s non-binary daughter. She’s a woman in real life..playing a man…maybe? Why cast a woman to play a male character? That’s the point. I was wondering if they’d show breasts during the autopsy. |
She / They doesn't have any. |
A lot of critics are lauding the series as a much closer adaptation of Highsmith's work. You do realize, don't you, that nonbinary people have existed since the dawn on time? Ancient Greece ring any bells for you? Ancient Rome? The repressed morality of the last few hundred years is an anomaly in the human experience, and the pendulum is swinging back. There are hundreds of species in the animal world where bisexuality has been observed - it is far more the norm in nature than religious conservatives want to acknowledge. I'm looking forward to seeing the adaptation and portrayal of Ripley by Andrew Scott, who I suspect does a much better embodiment than Damon, whose performance was very good. The choice of black and white is stylistic and I look forward to enjoying that, too - but I record tons of old movies on TCM so I'm used to the medium. Black and white film is really beautiful and also can be very eerie in a way that color film doesn't match. |
Really? But have you read all of Patricia HIGHSMITH'S novels? |
The actor playing Freddie is non-binary. Does that automatically mean that the character is? I am one of the non-intellectuals on here who did not read ALL of Highsmith's books, and Phillip Seymour Hoffman was definitely stuck in my head as the image of Freddie. Had a difficult time adjusting but that was true of all the characters for me. |