Yes, major matters as do essays. We have two kids who applied. One waitlisted - biology in 2021. Straight As, good rigor, iffy essays. Ultimately, withdrew from the waitlist. Her cousin with same stats and even more rigor was rejected at the last minute.
Our second kid - same major, slightly lower GPA but more rigor and better essays got in the following year but ED which no longer exists at Tech. |
PP here. Cousin waitlisted and then rejected to be more clear. |
If an in-state school at which your kid was waitlisted was really their #1 choice, did they subsequently inform the school that if accepted, they would definitely attend? That can often work for kids with stats way above the median for the school. And if they didn't do this, why not? Also, why apply to several top 10 schools if you wanted to pay in-state tutition? |
Itβs really hard to determine if essays really were the make or break factor. I know a lot of parents think their kidβs essays were amazing, but itβs really a subjective evaluation. I definitely think any student applying to Va tech should pay attention to the essay and the service component.
But that 40% first generation component is pretty significant and I think it knocks some kids out of the running for admission that werenβt being knocked out from some other schools. |
How can someone discern whether someone worked their tail off or treated it like a safety? |
They can't, the pp is writing codswallop. |
Personally, I think this is why VT should reinstate the ED. I know ED can be disadvantageous for certain people, but there are many high-stat Virginia kids whose first choice is VT. |
VT does not yield protect. I know some.people want to use this as an excuse for their kids not getting in, but that does not make it true. VT will definitely reject/waitlist a "high stats" kid that does not take the time to appropriately answer their 4 short essay questions. The 20:57 PP on page 2, for example, does not take the time to proofread their posts. Perhaps their essays were also riddled with grammatical errors.
|
Shots fired!
Different poster, but thereβs a different level of rigor and attention to detail needed for a college admissions essay vs a dcum post youβre probably doing in your phone. No need to be rude. |
Do you have any factual data to support that or you just talking nonsense? Your post very much and too many nonsense. Post very stupid, no understand. |
PP is talking codswallop. |
Yes, VT states their policy very clearly. Please read the note under the FAQs regarding yield protection. https://www.vt.edu/admissions/undergraduate/counselor-corner.html#:~:text=Virginia%20Tech%20does%20not%20participate%20in%20yield%20protection. |
I'm skeptical that the essays are of such importance that they are weighted the same as, or take precedence over, GPA, class rigor, test scores, etc. After all, essays are not infrequently written by parents, paid consultants, etc. rather than the applicant. And even if a first draft is written by the student, edits by other persons can result in a very different product. Also, please don't tell me that the reviewers can tell if an essay is not written by the applicant - they would have no way of knowing this. |
My kid will be turning down their Engineering spot for UMD |
It didn't take long for the "VT does not yield protect" crowd to show up, did it? You are wrong. Regardless of what their policy says, they do yield protect (or yield manage). Otherwise, you cannot explain the number of otherwise qualified kids that get waitlisted here but got into several other similar or higher ranked schools. Tech (along with NEU and UF) were safeties for my kid (a couple of years ago). He was waitlisted at Tech but got into the other two. I read all his essays and they were all of the same calibre. I may be biased about my kid's writing, but not so on a relative basis. We also know multiple kids that year and since with similar outcomes - didn't get into Tech, but did at higher ranked, more selective, schools. Can't explain that with "oh, they wrote poor essays because they were thinking it was a safety". No one does that. |